It is. I watched it recently and still can’t tell if it’s an early example of bleeding heart liberalism or an examination of how people can be swayed by a smooth talker. Or perhaps both at once.Watching 12 Angry Men for the first time in years. Brilliant film.
Mad Max 2 is probably the best in the franchise in my opinionWas washing the dishes earlier today with the One Show on in the background.During it I heard’get ready for the new blockbuster Mad Max film’. I must admit to never having seen a Mad Max film all the way through.So is there anyone here a fan of the franchise?
Alongside Ben Hur, it's my favourite movie of all time.Watching 12 Angry Men for the first time in years. Brilliant film.
Not watched the more recent ones that I can remember.Was washing the dishes earlier today with the One Show on in the background.During it I heard’get ready for the new blockbuster Mad Max film’. I must admit to never having seen a Mad Max film all the way through.So is there anyone here a fan of the franchise?
I loved it. Did a thread on it:Any thoughts on Civil War? I was really looking forward to it and enjoyed it, but it wasn't the stunner I hoped. Views?
I thought it was really well made and avoided the obvious partisan traps - the Western Alliance was Texas and California - the reddest and blueist states.I loved it. Did a thread on it:
Civil War | Frenchman's Cowshed
Good movie. Unless proven otherwise I assume everyone in Hollywood is on team progressive but I have to say they do an excellent job in not making it about that. The political origins of the fictitious war are rarely mentioned and then ambiguously - for example a fleeting remark about the...www.hibeesbounce.com
Great soundtrack, avoided taking sides in a bitch fest it is a critique of (much to the chagrin of partisans on all sides), well put together. A heart of darkness reprise for a dying age, just as the original was for a dying age.
Interested in the last bit if you don’t mind expanding. To perhaps pre-empt, I think that a ‘hot’ civil war is pretty implausible - most informed commentators seem to be of the view that any breakdown is more likely to resemble guerilla warfare or ‘just’ terrorism. However a secessionist pretext (as heavily implied) was just about credible enough for the suspension of disbelief to work imho.I thought it was really well made and avoided the obvious partisan traps - the Western Alliance was Texas and California - the reddest and blueist states.
I thought the exploration of the moral ambiguity of the war correspondent was just on the right side of overdone. I thought most of the leads were good, but less sure about Kirsten Dunst.
But I thought some of wider narrative was pretty implausible. It's a very good film, but not the stellar event I was hoping for.
Love Mel Gibson's Mad Max, not to keen on the new ones.Was washing the dishes earlier today with the One Show on in the background.During it I heard’get ready for the new blockbuster Mad Max film’. I must admit to never having seen a Mad Max film all the way through.So is there anyone here a fan of the franchise?
I think the lack of American forces in the film isn't plausible. I don't mean the Jesse Plemons scene where we don't know what side he is on. But the journey to the front had very little to give a sense of a mass battle looming. And when it sort of happened it wasn't really a battle. More an incursion.Interested in the last bit if you don’t mind expanding. To perhaps pre-empt, I think that a ‘hot’ civil war is pretty implausible - most informed commentators seem to be of the view that any breakdown is more likely to resemble guerilla warfare or ‘just’ terrorism. However a secessionist pretext (as heavily implied) was just about credible enough for the suspension of disbelief to work imho.
California plus Texas could probably muster something approximating an army, which is possibly a secondary reason for their pairing after thwarting attempts to align it all to contemporary tribalism.
Mass battles would be more implausible I think. See my previous for whyI think the lack of American forces in the film isn't plausible. I don't mean the Jesse Plemons scene where we don't know what side he is on. But the journey to the front had very little to give a sense of a mass battle looming. And when it sort of happened it wasn't really a battle. More an incursion.
They weren’t though. Not a criticism here, not least because wherever my mind was wandering at the time, I missed it too. The shopping scene depicts a Potemkin village. The whole place is bristling with armed defenders that allows a pretence of normal life, presumably extending to people pretending to themselves that the money they exchange means anything in a wider context,The US dollar had apparently collapsed, but stores seemed to operate as normal.
You can’t nuke your own country. And he could very well be exposed. Loathe him or not what is happening to trump demonstrates what can happen when real power turns against a president, ex or current.The end scenes, though thrilling, didn't ring true either. I just don't think he would be left that exposed or indeed be there at all. And then there is the elephant in the room - nuclear weapons.
Hard disagree here. The point as I took was it doesn’t matter what the beef is, this is where the US is headed, in approximate form, if it can’t handle that in a civilised way.I think the studied ambiguity and no context was necessary in some ways, but it meant we didn't have these broader issues addressed at all, which made it harder to build a plausible story.
Yeah it was, in every respect. Boiled down the nihilism of the whole thing into a few lines, made clear there will be no good guys if it hits the fan, and stylistically; bravura stuff.But don't get me wrong. I really liked it, but I wanted to love it. But I thought the very last scene was great.
I'm enjoying the perspective. Two quick points: nukes aren't just the big bombs - desperate men and all that; and the 'Potemkin village ' I took to be a place insulating itself from the war, as places in the US civil war tried to do.Mass battles would be more implausible I think. See my previous for why
They weren’t though. Not a criticism here, not least because wherever my mind was wandering at the time, I missed it too. The shopping scene depicts a Potemkin village. The whole place is bristling with armed defenders that allows a pretence of normal life, presumably extending to people pretending to themselves that the money they exchange means anything in a wider context,
You can’t nuke your own country. And he could very well be exposed. Loathe him or not what is happening to trump demonstrates what can happen when real power turns against a president, ex or current.
Hard disagree here. The point as I took was it doesn’t matter what the beef is, this is where the US is headed, in approximate form, if it can’t handle that in a civilised way.
Yeah it was, in every respect. Boiled down the nihilism of the whole thing into a few lines, made clear there will be no good guys if it hits the fan, and stylistically; bravura stuff.
Ps please don’t take the above as one of our tête-à-têtes, just a differing take.
‘Tactical nukes’? Still not sure an embattled president could launch them on his own turf. I’m not sure how it works tbh but it’s deffo not literally a button and he relies on people to execute I suspect. Don’t think it could happen in short.I'm enjoying the perspective. Two quick points: nukes aren't just the big bombs - desperate men and all that; and the 'Potemkin village ' I took to be a place insulating itself from the war, as places in the US civil war tried to do.
But in any event, the soldiers were universally brutal. And the journo's who died were the ones that intervened in the story!
It's an interesting point about loyalty. Clearly the 'American' forces have the president as commander in chief. Given how brutal civil wars are I'm less sure that wouldn't happen, especially as we saw what could happen if you were captured.‘Tactical nukes’? Still not sure an embattled president could launch them on his own turf. I’m not sure how it works tbh but it’s deffo not literally a button and he relies on people to execute I suspect. Don’t think it could happen in short.
That’s even if it were a president with popular support among the establishment. The film does go so far as to suggest a trump like figure and like I say, we’ve seen what Ryan might call the deep state and I’d, as above, call the establishment, can do their even in peace time.
I might once have believed Hollywood that the army was different and full of Jack Nicholson types from ‘a few good men’, but whether or not that was once true, it seems now to be led by Ivy League guys being ivy league guys - I can’t see them subscribing to a trump like figure wanting to use nukes within America. What would be more interesting is if in the event of a breakdown, whether the army would collapse along class lines, in some echo of revolutionary Russia.
This is worth a visit if you find yourself in San Diego USS Midway (CV-41) - WikipediaAside; a guy I knew some years back was former navy and had rubbed shoulders with the US navy. Some of the things he told me were wild if true. Some of the big US boats like aircraft carriers are like floating towns, with their own ‘neighbourhoods’. By his telling, white officers couldn’t go into the hood (so to speak) without armed escorts,
All kinds of dynamics are waiting to pop out if it ever hits the fan.
Beyond Thunderdome was the best Mad Max, if only for the theme tune.Was washing the dishes earlier today with the One Show on in the background.During it I heard’get ready for the new blockbuster Mad Max film’. I must admit to never having seen a Mad Max film all the way through.So is there anyone here a fan of the franchise?
thats a loady shite. The boy was pulling yer pudding. White officers wi armed escorts!!! mon tae...Aside; a guy I knew some years back was former navy and had rubbed shoulders with the US navy. Some of the things he told me were wild if true. Some of the big US boats like aircraft carriers are like floating towns, with their own ‘neighbourhoods’. By his telling, white officers couldn’t go into the hood (so to speak) without armed escorts,
All kinds of dynamics are waiting to pop out if it ever hits the fan.
76yrs ago thenThis is worth a visit if you find yourself in San Diego USS Midway (CV-41) - Wikipedia
It had a crew of over 4,000! The wiki piece has an eye opening discussion about a visit to South Africa. Worth remembering that segregation in US forces was only ended in 1948.
There's a very interesting discussion about the segregation in the US army and the issues it caused in the UK. Here's an interesting piece76yrs ago then
theconversation.com
Well I'd known the guy for a long long time. I don't think he was making it up. Someone may have sold him a pup mind you.thats a loady shite. The boy was pulling yer pudding. White officers wi armed escorts!!! mon tae...
Sure you wernae chatting about US prisons rather than the US navy??
yes, knew about this.There's a very interesting discussion about the segregation in the US army and the issues it caused in the UK. Here's an interesting piece
![]()
Black troops were welcome in Britain, but Jim Crow wasn’t: the race riot of one night in June 1943
When black American troops stationed in an English town faced off against white US Army military police.theconversation.com
Well I'd known the guy for a long long time. I don't think he was making it up. Someone may have sold him a pup mind you.
I just googled it and there's chat from former US navy bods suggesting it happened in the 70s on specific ships but has become exaggerated story since then and no longer the case these days. The guy I spoke with would have been navy late 80s / early 90s so has either heard a tale from older guys that remember those days or else the exaggerated myths that followed.
Very droll. But the world is not always as sanitised as life in contemporary Edinburgh may suggest.I heard they let them identify as cats and have litter trays on the poop deck these days.

Oi you stop causing troubleAnybody watched any good movies lately?
![]()
What's it aboot?Oi you stop causing trouble
Dinnae need a fork in Moredun. just knife tae butter Fergie's rolls. I ate 6 of the fuckers on Wednesday morning, greedy bastardA refugee from Gracemount who learns how to use a knife. In conjunction with a fork obviously as you've moved to Moredun.

Hard to disagree with that BillyDinnae need a fork in Moredun. just knife tae butter Fergie's rolls. I ate 6 of the fuckers on Wednesday morning, greedy bastard![]()
Got 2 for Freddie but the cvnt didnae turn up.Hard to disagree with that Billy![]()
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.