Civil War

egb_hibs

Private Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2002
Good movie. Unless proven otherwise I assume everyone in Hollywood is on team progressive but I have to say they do an excellent job in not making it about that. The political origins of the fictitious war are rarely mentioned and then ambiguously - for example a fleeting remark about the ‘antifa massacre’ doesn’t elaborate on whether antifa was getting massacred or doing the massacring.

This seems to have given the hump to both maga and blue haired types I’ve read on the tinternet, which is probably a sign of a job well done. Instead of the a chest thumping polemic, there isn’t much narrative at all, it’s more a heart of darkness (more so the book than Apocalypse Now) wander ‘up river’, or in this case across wrecked hinterlands, encountering splintered set pieces of madness. For example, two antifa snipers (again it’s not spelled out, just their hair dye and nail varnish implying it - other protagonists sport the Hawaiian shirts of the boogaloo boys) firing into a house from which an unknown someone fires back, neither side having an identified faction or knowing that of the other. This is straight out of Heart of Darkness where the plot-lost crew of a gunboat sit off the coast shelling an unseen foe in the rain forest.

It’s got a thumping soundtrack, with Suicide playing a particularly tremendous role at ear splitting volume and crystal clear - Rocket USA being particularly effective as a backdrop to a hallucinatory descent.

If it’s got any theme it’s use of press photographers cataloguing the carnage is probably indicative. To quote Mrs EGB afterwards - whose normal fare is Call the midwife - “it’s about voyuerism and what is doing to us innit?”. I think she is probably right. My daughter declared it the scariest film she’d ever seen.

Recommended.


To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Yes, I really liked it.

The clear message to me was: This is what's coming if you keep up the tribalism... and you really don't want it.

Sadly, I think the amount of folk getting their knickers in a twist about this film shows that many believe tribalism only applies to the side they aren't on.

In a world where "centrist" has become an insult, I think a film this stark and hard about what happens when finding common ground becomes impossible and people allow fascism in by the back door is absolutely to be applauded.

Also, on a technical level I think the way the violence in the film is shot is to be applauded. It's terrifying. This could have been fluffy comic book satire that fell flat and it is anything but - It's a gut punch.

If I had any criticism, I thought some of the efforts to keep it politically neutral were a little contrived such as the antifa comment you mentioned and the California/Texas WF alliance but honestly I couldn't think of a better way to have done it.
 
Sounds good. Is this available on any of the legitimate streaming services, or cinema only for just now?
 
Sounds good. Is this available on any of the legitimate streaming services, or cinema only for just now?
Don’t know, but i will say it’s worth a trip to the flix, ideally IMAX. It’s designed to be overwhelming and I think it’s worth seeing it at the cinema. I never mentioned it but the battle scenes are up there with anything in recent memory; but think of Saving Private Ryan vs Rambo
 
Yes, I really liked it.

The clear message to me was: This is what's coming if you keep up the tribalism... and you really don't want it.

Sadly, I think the amount of folk getting their knickers in a twist about this film shows that many believe tribalism only applies to the side they aren't on.

In a world where "centrist" has become an insult, I think a film this stark and hard about what happens when finding common ground becomes impossible and people allow fascism in by the back door is absolutely to be applauded.

Also, on a technical level I think the way the violence in the film is shot is to be applauded. It's terrifying. This could have been fluffy comic book satire that fell flat and it is anything but - It's a gut punch.

If I had any criticism, I thought some of the efforts to keep it politically neutral were a little contrived such as the antifa comment you mentioned and the California/Texas WF alliance but honestly I couldn't think of a better way to have done it.
I think that’s spot on, though I didn’t have an issue with the bits you feel contrived. I read the WF is intentional - ie it’s intended to confound attempts to impose political sides onto it. There are other subtle things in the same vein; the guys in the Hawaiian shirts are mixed race, where irl it’s the ‘uniform’ of white nationalists for example. (Although they are not all white in real life either, the label ‘white supremacism’ no longer meaning what one might think - maybe it’s a subtle jab at this kind of thing).

I think his point is much like you said: it doesn’t matter what tribe you align with, if things become unmoored it’s a one way trip to hell and everyone becomes bad guys. I don’t think centrists get away completely unscathed. I think the photographers lines about observing but not taking sides, is not just about voyuerism but also a reminder that attempted neutrality won’t save you if it goes sideways,
 
On the other hand.....just another opinion.



BIG G
Opinions are like aresholes as they say; everybody’s got one.

However, I do think this writer has missed the point, and I say that with a degree of confidence as my impression corresponds with what the writer / director has said was his intent. The depoliticised mode of the film is meant to stop people rooting for anyone and basically show what can happen when polarisation leads to complete breakdown. It’s a warning.

Also, how in the world this could be interpreted as flattering to the photographers is beyond me. I’ll say no more in order to avoid spoilers, but that is some stretch.

As I said in my OP ideological reviewers from different camps seem uncomfortable with the approach. I think that tells its own story.
 
Don’t know, but i will say it’s worth a trip to the flix, ideally IMAX. It’s designed to be overwhelming and I think it’s worth seeing it at the cinema. I never mentioned it but the battle scenes are up there with anything in recent memory; but think of Saving Private Ryan vs Rambo
A wee trip to IMAX on Sunday. At least we'll be safe from real snipers.
 
Watched this last night. I thought it was boring except for one scene. I nearly switched it off with 10-15 minutes left. If anything it’s similar to The Walking Dead.
 
Yes, I really liked it.

The clear message to me was: This is what's coming if you keep up the tribalism... and you really don't want it.

Sadly, I think the amount of folk getting their knickers in a twist about this film shows that many believe tribalism only applies to the side they aren't on.

In a world where "centrist" has become an insult, I think a film this stark and hard about what happens when finding common ground becomes impossible and people allow fascism in by the back door is absolutely to be applauded.

Also, on a technical level I think the way the violence in the film is shot is to be applauded. It's terrifying. This could have been fluffy comic book satire that fell flat and it is anything but - It's a gut punch.

If I had any criticism, I thought some of the efforts to keep it politically neutral were a little contrived such as the antifa comment you mentioned and the California/Texas WF alliance but honestly I couldn't think of a better way to have done it.
Agree with your post except I would change the word fascism for extremism as it exists on all sides and it is too easy to look at only one tribe and call them fascist whilst the left are as or even more extreme in the pushing of their own rhetoric.
 
Watched this last night. I thought it was boring except for one scene. I nearly switched it off with 10-15 minutes left. If anything it’s similar to The Walking Dead.
Might watch it, but was thinking it could just be yet another of the endless after the armageddon type movies