Full Time: St Johnstone 1 v 3 Hibernian

Forums New posts
Peevemor said:
You tried to ridicule a post of mine that was factually correct. You didn't give give an opinion to counter that, just juvenile shite.
Click to expand...

Ridicule your post, I mentioned my reason as to why my opinion was different from yours. Juvenile shite is when you make your post in a larger format which you had done 🙈😉
 
Hammi said:
Nothing wrong with wanting better.
I want better. Every player at every club can be replaced with better.

But you get rid of your worst players and give your better players competition for places.

You don't start at the top and work your way down.
Click to expand...

Thats your opinion, last week was a crucial game and Campbell had no positive impact on the game. I personally want better.
 
The Family said:
Ridicule your post, I mentioned my reason as to why my opinion was different from yours. Juvenile shite is when you make your post in a larger format which you had done 🙈😉
Click to expand...
I don't even know how to. Stop making things up.
 
The Family said:
Thats your opinion, last week was a crucial game and Campbell had no positive impact on the game. I personally want better.
Click to expand...
I don't really rate him TBH and would like to see us sign better.

But my point still stands about the important goals he's scored for us in the past.
 
Greenmachine said:
Thing is, this match is hugely important for St Johnstone who are still very much relegation candidates. They have to win against Hibs. This is another drawback of finishing bottom six. Most of the clubs we will be playing now are desperate for points to avoid being drawn into the play-off spot.

No matter how you look at it, this season has been an unmitigated failure with everyone, bar the hugely loyal and terrific fanbase, playing their part in that failure.
Click to expand...
I don’t think the catering staff are to blame.
 
tayside hibee said:
Your making a bit of a tit of yourself.
there was a few culprits at Motherwell, Campbell wasn't one of them .
Click to expand...

A tit of myself, why because Campbell was shite last week in our last competitive game of the season. Look at the thread on who I chose to keep and the rest can do one. The replacements I chose in my opinion are a much better than the likes of him, Newell, Boyle, Youan to name but a few.
 
The Family said:
A tit of myself, why because Campbell was shite last week in our last competitive game of the season. Look at the thread on who I chose to keep and the rest can do one. The replacements I chose in my opinion are a much better than the likes of him, Newell, Boyle, Youan to name but a few.
Click to expand...
You were arguing against a point that nobody made.
 
Peevemor said:
I don't really rate him TBH and would like to see us sign better.

But my point still stands about the important goals he's scored for us in the past.
Click to expand...

In the past. But I was referring to his overall performances in games. Taking his goals out of it, I didn’t see much that made me think to want to build our midfield around him. Moriah Welsh offers a lot more than Josh and that’s who I would be building my midfield around for next season.
 
Peevemor said:
You were arguing against a point that nobody made.
Click to expand...

I wasn’t arguing at all, just because I posted something you didn’t agree with, I can do the same with your post but I am not calling you out on it, it’s your opinion.
 
The Family said:
Thats your opinion, last week was a crucial game and Campbell had no positive impact on the game. I personally want better.
Click to expand...

I'm used to disagreeing with you,
But im genuinely gobsmacked.

It was his first appearance since being injured in December. He's back, ahead of schedule and came off the bench with 10 minutes left to play. What did you actually expect him to do? If anything that probably wasn't the moment to bring him back. That's not his fault.

I'd happily replace any player at Hibs. Every single one of them. If they're replaced with better.

There's probably about 15 players at the club I'd get rid of before Josh Campbell.
 
Come on Ross County. Massive opportunity to move out of the play off spot. I'd happily take a loss against RC just to potentially send Levein down. A little revenge against St J's for beating us twice in the cup anaw 🤣
 
The Family said:
In the past. But I was referring to his overall performances in games. Taking his goals out of it, I didn’t see much that made me think to want to build our midfield around him. Moriah Welsh offers a lot more than Josh and that’s who I would be building my midfield around for next season.
Click to expand...
Hope you're happy with yourself. You've won your argument against no-one.
 
Hammi said:
I'm used to disagreeing with you,
But im genuinely gobsmacked.

It was his first appearance since being injured in December. He's back, ahead of schedule and came off the bench with 10 minutes left to play. What did you actually expect him to do?

I'd happily replace any player at Hibs. Every single one of them. If they're replaced with better.

There's probably about 15 players at the club I'd get rid of before Josh Campbell.
Click to expand...

But you just agreed that you also wanted better. Just because I post something that you don’t agree with it must be wrong eh.

At the end of the day I don’t think he is good enough.
 
The Family said:
Thats your opinion, last week was a crucial game and Campbell had no positive impact on the game. I personally want better.
Click to expand...
Tbf that was Campbell’s 1st game back after months out with a fractured ankle, can hardly expect him to be right back at it right away . I agree before that he was more cold than hot but he is a decent squad player for us, there are others I would move on before him
 
C4MMY said:
Tbf that was Campbell’s 1st game back after months out with a fractured ankle, can hardly expect him to be right back at it right away . I agree before that he was more cold than hot but he is a decent squad player for us, there are others I would move on before him
Click to expand...

As I mentioned previously, my decision wasn’t based over one game mate.
 
The Family said:
But you just agreed that you also wanted better. Just because I post something that you don’t agree with it must be wrong eh.

At the end of the day I don’t think he is good enough.
Click to expand...

None of them are really good enough. We're 7th ffs.

But you actually said above "taking his goals out of it"
Why?
Why would you take the single most important thing about a game of football out of the equation?
Mental

I do want better. But I'd be getting rod of your JDH's, Jairs, Hendo2 etc long long before I thought about Josh. You can't clear the whole squad and start fresh, so you have to keep some of the players going forward.

He has value to the club, if someone is better than him, then they play, but I know Josh works for the team, is a proper team player, is one of us and loves wearing the colours. He also scores and assists.
Hes well down my list, hes earned a spot at the table and I 'd have him on the bench with the Moriah-Welshes of the world starting games.

I like him, I think there's still plenty more to come from him. He just needs to stick at it.
 
Last edited:
Hammi said:
None of them are really good enough. We're 7th ffs.

But you actually said above "taking his goals out of it"
Why?
Why would you take the single most important thing about a game of football out of the equation?
Mental

I do want better. But I'd be getting rod of your JDH's, Jairs, Hendo2 etc long long before I thought about Josh. You can't clear the whole squad and start fresh, so you have to keep some of the players going forward.

He has value to the club, if someone is better than him, then they play, but I know Josh works for the team, is a proper team player, is one of us and loves wearing the colours. He also scores and assists.
Hes well down my list, hes earned a spot at the table and I 'd have him on the bench with the Moriah-Welshes of the world starting games.
Click to expand...

Exactly, we did finish 7th and that is why I am wanting rid of most of these players.
 
Rockys attempts at going down when touched look terrible it surprises me he gets them. Should be going down less theatrically 😂
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
  • Menu
  • Home
  • Hibs Chat
  • New Posts
  • Just Back
  • Chatroom