Rumour.

Forums New posts
Screenshot_20260603_124610_X.jpg
Dunno if we can take much stock from a guy who cant spell Hibernian but he does seem to have a good amount of followers.
 
greencol said:
Not really a surprise.
The bubble blowers wont be his only suitors.
Click to expand...

To lose him and Chaiwa plus add on to what we already need it's gonna be a busy summer. Hope we don't get to pre season with no players in and hearing the usual excuses.
 
Hammi said:
Both leave the day before the 2nd leg of whatever euro tie
Leave us up shit creek
Click to expand...
Can't help but feel like this is quite a likely scenario.

Is it just me, or -- like, I know we've always been a selling club, that's just the reality. But it feels like over the last few years, we see less and less of the outstanding players we bring to the club? Or is that just recency bias? The likes of Bowie, Chaiwa, Mulligan, it just feels like we hardly even get a season out of them before "cheerio". (Acknowledging the role injuries play here, too.)
 
aggie said:
Can't help but feel like this is quite a likely scenario.

Is it just me, or -- like, I know we've always been a selling club, that's just the reality. But it feels like over the last few years, we see less and less of the outstanding players we bring to the club? Or is that just recency bias? The likes of Bowie, Chaiwa, Mulligan, it just feels like we hardly even get a season out of them before "cheerio". (Acknowledging the role injuries play here, too.)
Click to expand...
Was just making this exact point on a Hibs Whatsapp chat. Any kind of form shown by any of our players and it feels like it's "cheery" :bye:

Barely even get half a season out of our top performers and they're out the door. I know he's recently departed for the Huns, but Shankland for me has been far and away the outstanding striker in the league for years and the Gunts got 4 years out of him. Feel like sometimes we need to put the product on the park first.

It's the silly season though so this could all be BS.
 
Us collectively are half the problem. A player has a good 6months at the cabbage and half the fan boards are salivating at the prospect of selling them.

Its a hangover from the farmer/petrie days imo
 
Last edited:
emerald green said:
US collectively are half the problem. A player has a good 6months at the cabbage and have the fan boards are salivating at the prospect of selling them.

Its a hangover from the farmer/petrie days imo
Click to expand...

Or we don't want us to sell, then when we actually hold on instead of selling they turn against us and we go mad that we didn't.

Youan, Nisbet being recent examples
 
Hibee Kev said:
Barely even get half a season out of our top performers and they're out the door. I know he's recently departed for the Huns, but Shankland for me has been far and away the outstanding striker in the league for years and the Gunts got 4 years out of him. Feel like sometimes we need to put the product on the park first.
Click to expand...

I agree.

But just on Shankland, I'm no sure he's really good enough to play anywhere else, that'll pay similarly.
But he's clever enough to make up for his shortfalls.

Hunco couldn't afford him 2 years ago, then he had a bad year going into last summer so wasn't wanted.
Hearts paid him their best ever contract to keep him for 3 years (ahem 😂) and he finally gets the Hunco move.

He's a top end SPL forward, but physically he's held back from managing anywhere else it seems.

They'll lose all their players with potential soon, same as we would.
 
Hibee Kev said:
Was just making this exact point on a Hibs Whatsapp chat. Any kind of form shown by any of our players and it feels like it's "cheery" :bye:

Barely even get half a season out of our top performers and they're out the door. I know he's recently departed for the Huns, but Shankland for me has been far and away the outstanding striker in the league for years and the Gunts got 4 years out of him. Feel like sometimes we need to put the product on the park first.

It's the silly season though so this could all be BS.
Click to expand...
Shankland was garbage last year
 
aggie said:
Can't help but feel like this is quite a likely scenario.

Is it just me, or -- like, I know we've always been a selling club, that's just the reality. But it feels like over the last few years, we see less and less of the outstanding players we bring to the club? Or is that just recency bias? The likes of Bowie, Chaiwa, Mulligan, it just feels like we hardly even get a season out of them before "cheerio". (Acknowledging the role injuries play here, too.)
Click to expand...
Sometimes we don't even get to see them!

I'm sure we've lost a couple of youngsters to English clubs for a decent wedge. A possible reason we're not seeing as many as we might come through our academy.
 
Keeping the Mulligan, McGrath, Chaiwa trio needs to be a priority.

Some explaining will need to be done if we lose one or more of them.
 
wrighty said:
Keeping the Mulligan, McGrath, Chaiwa trio needs to be a priority.

Some explaining will need to be done if we lose one or more of them.
Click to expand...

Might not be much to explain.
Received an offer, player wants to go
All parties happy.


McGrath least likely to go I think. Then Chaiwa.
Mulligan will have interest. No chance he doesn't look incredible on a spreadsheet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
  • Menu
  • Home
  • Hibs Chat
  • New Posts
  • Just Back
  • Chatroom