How woke is too woke?

Funny you mention that EG. A wee while ago I did attempt to get some conversation flowing from the many 'wimmin protectors' on here, following the publishing of the second Angiolini report. Wanted to hear more on their thoughts, feelings and ideas around this passion they have to make life safer for women and girls, and the proposals within the report:


Alas, barring a couple of half-hearted attempts, it was tumbleweed. Seems this late-in-life desire to 'protect wimmin' is strictly segregated (pun intended) for them transgenders only. It does make one wonder why though? What is it about transgender folk that triggers the boomers and gen x-ers so much, if its not actually the reason they say it is?

I do have a theory. Maybe I'll pop that on a thread of its own one day; potentially more chance of traction..
Well in my younger days I used to spark cnuts abusing them, including stopping a rape about to commence, if that helps likes. So not so late life for me.

I wish I could be convinced you cared about it rather than trying to make everything fit with your narrative view.

Looking forward to what freud-by-numbers your tranny thesis entails!
 
Well in my younger days I used to spark cnuts abusing them, including stopping a rape about to commence, if that helps likes. So not so late life for me.

I wish I could be convinced you cared about it rather than trying to make everything fit with your narrative view.

Looking forward to what freud-by-numbers your tranny thesis entails!
Top man, thank you!
 
Funny you mention that EG. A wee while ago I did attempt to get some conversation flowing from the many 'wimmin protectors' on here, following the publishing of the second Angiolini report. Wanted to hear more on their thoughts, feelings and ideas around this passion they have to make life safer for women and girls, and the proposals within the report:


Alas, barring a couple of half-hearted attempts, it was tumbleweed. Seems this late-in-life desire to 'protect wimmin' is strictly segregated (pun intended) for them transgenders only. It does make one wonder why though? What is it about transgender folk that triggers the boomers and gen x-ers so much, if its not actually the reason they say it is?

I do have a theory. Maybe I'll pop that on a thread of its own one day; potentially more chance of traction..
I think you should post your 'theory'. It would be a good basis for debate.

As for the 'late in life' observation , surely that is a result of the issue as we understand now being a recent development? I remember when travelling there would be places where transvestites were not just tolerated but celebrated. Paddington in Sydney being a prime example. Drag was really popular. And very few people seemed to care about the Ladyboys of Bangkok annual visit to the Fringe.

So what changed? To my mind it was a politically driven move to shift people dressing or acting as the opposite sex to something more profound - that people actually changed sex. That's a pretty dramatic reframing of thousands of years of social relationships.

The tactics were a mix of stealth and aggression. People try to do the right thing as they see it, but with no debate mantra, how could it be questioned? And that was essential as there are key questions:
- what does trans actually mean?
- what exactly is non-binary?
- is two spirit really a thing?

But addressing these questions needed to be avoided because there is no broadly accepted answer.

Let's take self ID. If someone can sign a bit of paper to say they have changed sex, what has actually changed? The answer is we don't know. The spectrum goes from nothing right through to full physical transition. But if we take m to f transition, are we really saying that someone signs a piece of paper and does nothing else that they are a woman for all intents and purposes? Because if you agree with that then terms like 'lady penis' will cause you no concern at all.

But the next part needed to make this work was no challenge acceptance. And we've seen this play out in recent court cases and tribunals. This can only work if same sex spaces aren't same sex spaces. Unless you argue that a m to f trans person is actually a woman then the whole edifice collapses. You are saying that women who don't wish a biological man in same sex spaces has no right to object on any grounds: moral, religious or fear.

And this was promoted by politicians and campaign groups. Stonewall called lesbians who didn't want to have sex with trans men 'sexual racists'. Which flies in the face of everything about unpressured consent.

Why? I think garbled sense of trying to do the right thing coupled with limited space in the economic sphere to be 'progressive'.

Had the campaign had a little give and take, coupled with a sense that some people need boundaries, then I think there would be general acceptance. But there was no give and take.

That was bad enough, but the fatal error to my mind was kids. Pushing for a single response to confused kids - the affirmation approach with related physical and medical interventions is just wrong. And it happened. Just look up Mermaids. It's horrifying. And in many cases driven by rampant homophobia.

I suspect most people would say adults can do what they want, but kids? A step too far.

Do I care if people dress and act as the opposite sex? No. Do I care if people say they are the opposite sex and I have to agree and comply? Yes. Be it same sex care, single sex provision, sports and social on I think people have the right to organise along biological sex lines.

Feel free to make the argument why you thing I'm wrong.
 
I think you should post your 'theory'. It would be a good basis for debate.

As for the 'late in life' observation , surely that is a result of the issue as we understand now being a recent development? I remember when travelling there would be places where transvestites were not just tolerated but celebrated. Paddington in Sydney being a prime example. Drag was really popular. And very few people seemed to care about the Ladyboys of Bangkok annual visit to the Fringe.

So what changed? To my mind it was a politically driven move to shift people dressing or acting as the opposite sex to something more profound - that people actually changed sex. That's a pretty dramatic reframing of thousands of years of social relationships.

The tactics were a mix of stealth and aggression. People try to do the right thing as they see it, but with no debate mantra, how could it be questioned? And that was essential as there are key questions:
- what does trans actually mean?
- what exactly is non-binary?
- is two spirit really a thing?

But addressing these questions needed to be avoided because there is no broadly accepted answer.

Let's take self ID. If someone can sign a bit of paper to say they have changed sex, what has actually changed? The answer is we don't know. The spectrum goes from nothing right through to full physical transition. But if we take m to f transition, are we really saying that someone signs a piece of paper and does nothing else that they are a woman for all intents and purposes? Because if you agree with that then terms like 'lady penis' will cause you no concern at all.

But the next part needed to make this work was no challenge acceptance. And we've seen this play out in recent court cases and tribunals. This can only work if same sex spaces aren't same sex spaces. Unless you argue that a m to f trans person is actually a woman then the whole edifice collapses. You are saying that women who don't wish a biological man in same sex spaces has no right to object on any grounds: moral, religious or fear.

And this was promoted by politicians and campaign groups. Stonewall called lesbians who didn't want to have sex with trans men 'sexual racists'. Which flies in the face of everything about unpressured consent.

Why? I think garbled sense of trying to do the right thing coupled with limited space in the economic sphere to be 'progressive'.

Had the campaign had a little give and take, coupled with a sense that some people need boundaries, then I think there would be general acceptance. But there was no give and take.

That was bad enough, but the fatal error to my mind was kids. Pushing for a single response to confused kids - the affirmation approach with related physical and medical interventions is just wrong. And it happened. Just look up Mermaids. It's horrifying. And in many cases driven by rampant homophobia.

I suspect most people would say adults can do what they want, but kids? A step too far.

Do I care if people dress and act as the opposite sex? No. Do I care if people say they are the opposite sex and I have to agree and comply? Yes. Be it same sex care, single sex provision, sports and social on I think people have the right to organise along biological sex lines.

Feel free to make the argument why you thing I'm wrong.
Excellent post, @Archie
 
I think you should post your 'theory'. It would be a good basis for debate.

As for the 'late in life' observation , surely that is a result of the issue as we understand now being a recent development? I remember when travelling there would be places where transvestites were not just tolerated but celebrated. Paddington in Sydney being a prime example. Drag was really popular. And very few people seemed to care about the Ladyboys of Bangkok annual visit to the Fringe.

So what changed? To my mind it was a politically driven move to shift people dressing or acting as the opposite sex to something more profound - that people actually changed sex. That's a pretty dramatic reframing of thousands of years of social relationships.

The tactics were a mix of stealth and aggression. People try to do the right thing as they see it, but with no debate mantra, how could it be questioned? And that was essential as there are key questions:
- what does trans actually mean?
- what exactly is non-binary?
- is two spirit really a thing?

But addressing these questions needed to be avoided because there is no broadly accepted answer.

Let's take self ID. If someone can sign a bit of paper to say they have changed sex, what has actually changed? The answer is we don't know. The spectrum goes from nothing right through to full physical transition. But if we take m to f transition, are we really saying that someone signs a piece of paper and does nothing else that they are a woman for all intents and purposes? Because if you agree with that then terms like 'lady penis' will cause you no concern at all.

But the next part needed to make this work was no challenge acceptance. And we've seen this play out in recent court cases and tribunals. This can only work if same sex spaces aren't same sex spaces. Unless you argue that a m to f trans person is actually a woman then the whole edifice collapses. You are saying that women who don't wish a biological man in same sex spaces has no right to object on any grounds: moral, religious or fear.

And this was promoted by politicians and campaign groups. Stonewall called lesbians who didn't want to have sex with trans men 'sexual racists'. Which flies in the face of everything about unpressured consent.

Why? I think garbled sense of trying to do the right thing coupled with limited space in the economic sphere to be 'progressive'.

Had the campaign had a little give and take, coupled with a sense that some people need boundaries, then I think there would be general acceptance. But there was no give and take.

That was bad enough, but the fatal error to my mind was kids. Pushing for a single response to confused kids - the affirmation approach with related physical and medical interventions is just wrong. And it happened. Just look up Mermaids. It's horrifying. And in many cases driven by rampant homophobia.

I suspect most people would say adults can do what they want, but kids? A step too far.

Do I care if people dress and act as the opposite sex? No. Do I care if people say they are the opposite sex and I have to agree and comply? Yes. Be it same sex care, single sex provision, sports and social on I think people have the right to organise along biological sex lines.

Feel free to make the argument why you thing I'm wrong.
Yup great post Archie 👍

I'll make the assumption the 'you' in there is not me in particular, as I've yet to posit my thoughts on much of what you've written. Fwiw, many of the points you've made are very much along my thinking too.

Will get the theory posted at some point soon. Need the keyboard for that one, fat finger typing won't do it 🤣
 
Last edited:
I think you should post your 'theory'. It would be a good basis for debate.

As for the 'late in life' observation , surely that is a result of the issue as we understand now being a recent development? I remember when travelling there would be places where transvestites were not just tolerated but celebrated. Paddington in Sydney being a prime example. Drag was really popular. And very few people seemed to care about the Ladyboys of Bangkok annual visit to the Fringe.

So what changed? To my mind it was a politically driven move to shift people dressing or acting as the opposite sex to something more profound - that people actually changed sex. That's a pretty dramatic reframing of thousands of years of social relationships.

The tactics were a mix of stealth and aggression. People try to do the right thing as they see it, but with no debate mantra, how could it be questioned? And that was essential as there are key questions:
- what does trans actually mean?
- what exactly is non-binary?
- is two spirit really a thing?

But addressing these questions needed to be avoided because there is no broadly accepted answer.

Let's take self ID. If someone can sign a bit of paper to say they have changed sex, what has actually changed? The answer is we don't know. The spectrum goes from nothing right through to full physical transition. But if we take m to f transition, are we really saying that someone signs a piece of paper and does nothing else that they are a woman for all intents and purposes? Because if you agree with that then terms like 'lady penis' will cause you no concern at all.

But the next part needed to make this work was no challenge acceptance. And we've seen this play out in recent court cases and tribunals. This can only work if same sex spaces aren't same sex spaces. Unless you argue that a m to f trans person is actually a woman then the whole edifice collapses. You are saying that women who don't wish a biological man in same sex spaces has no right to object on any grounds: moral, religious or fear.

And this was promoted by politicians and campaign groups. Stonewall called lesbians who didn't want to have sex with trans men 'sexual racists'. Which flies in the face of everything about unpressured consent.

Why? I think garbled sense of trying to do the right thing coupled with limited space in the economic sphere to be 'progressive'.

Had the campaign had a little give and take, coupled with a sense that some people need boundaries, then I think there would be general acceptance. But there was no give and take.

That was bad enough, but the fatal error to my mind was kids. Pushing for a single response to confused kids - the affirmation approach with related physical and medical interventions is just wrong. And it happened. Just look up Mermaids. It's horrifying. And in many cases driven by rampant homophobia.

I suspect most people would say adults can do what they want, but kids? A step too far.

Do I care if people dress and act as the opposite sex? No. Do I care if people say they are the opposite sex and I have to agree and comply? Yes. Be it same sex care, single sex provision, sports and social on I think people have the right to organise along biological sex lines.

Feel free to make the argument why you thing I'm wrong.
Excellent Archie.

To which I would append that there is another rubicon element : people are being asked to deny objective reality to appease how others would prefer things to be. It's a constant thread in utopian politics but really went overground here.

Then there is the data: the huge clustering of trans women around thoroughly heterosexual men who are clearly fetishists in large part, and conversely the even greater clustering of trans men around vulnerable autistic young women. Neither is remotely akin to, say, the physiologically intersex experience.
 
Yup great post Archie 👍

I'll make the assumption the 'you' in there is not me in particular, as I've yet to posit my thoughts on much of what you've written. Fwiw, many of the points you've made are very much along my thinking too.

Will get the theory posted at some point soon. Need the keyboard for that one, far finger typing won't do it 🤣
Thanks. Whether the 'you' is you in particular rather depends on what you post! Looking forward to reading it.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I'd agree and for clarity I'm not claiming its not, my interest I suppose lies in how we prevent what can be (as the rest of your post illustrates) the most negative aspects of that reaction? thats what i was clumsily trying to nudge us towards with the hastily written post above

There's a tendency on both the left and right to seek to shut down views that are considered outwith the acceptable - we all do it and I suppose we might consider that there are good reasons for doing so - some ideas are dangerous, have negative impacts on society, are factually incorrect, are expressed by people we don't like/respect, we have limited time and patience etc etc. I'd acknowledge that the liberal ascendancy has meant that the victims of cancel culture have largely been inflicted on conservative views. I do think as well there's been a general lowering of tolerance of other views in the social media age.

a culture that fosters honesty and open debate takes a lot of effort and bandwidth the bounce on its better days is a great example of that but equally there are days when it feels a bit less than convivial. I'm actively trying at the moment to find points of agreement with the american right (based on my presumption they are setting the tone in UK) and where possible suppress my instincts to shout down all the silly views they have ;P so expect to see more posts about such luminaries as Tucker Carlson, nick feuntes, candace owens, MTG and the Trumpmeister himself - this isn't to say I paid no attention before its just I'm trying harder perhaps on reflection on some of this thread and for example the murder of CK - be interested to know your thoughts on this approach and who if anyone your trying to understand better on the left - where is your common ground? for example it has been refreshing to learn the American right are now broadly becoming more wary of corporate rule/over reach (eg equity funds purchasing domestic housing and the rentier trend) and anti-war.

I'm off to buy the world a coke ;P
@gun ainm, in service to your project of reading across the lines, you may find this worthwhile.

Here we have, once again, the far right (I would class the beardy guy in the middle as one - yet another new atheist mugged by reality - though might be unfair on the others) talking like a far left that understands economics and is able to engage with reality rather than being constrained by religious doctrine.

This is about economics not migration (economics being the root cause in the baity title)

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
These fuckers are bonkers Sancho. They seem to have a perpetual hatred of folk in the west.

Hopefully Santa gives them fuck all and shites in their living rooms.
It's fuckin outrageous, destroying childhood beliefs simply to make Santa some other race or religion or even gender.

If they stop portraying Santa as a fat speccy bearded old bloke, how the fuck am I going to entice small children into my van?
 
@gun ainm, in service to your project of reading across the lines, you may find this worthwhile.

Here we have, once again, the far right (I would class the beardy guy in the middle as one - yet another new atheist mugged by reality - though might be unfair on the others) talking like a far left that understands economics and is able to engage with reality rather than being constrained by religious doctrine.

This is about economics not migration (economics being the root cause in the baity title)

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

thanks - I got ~12 mins but not really impressed with the quality of the debate (how the fuck do they have 500k+ subs?) - I broadly agree that an economy based on debt and rent seeking is a disaster and its cute they just seem to have realised this - but what am I supposed to be learning here? which beardy guy is the far right and what makes him so? followed the trail to esteemed Rupert Lowe MP - another multi-millionaire ex Reform guy.
 
thanks - I got ~12 mins but not really impressed with the quality of the debate (how the fuck do they have 500k+ subs?) - I broadly agree that an economy based on debt and rent seeking is a disaster and its cute they just seem to have realised this - but what am I supposed to be learning here? which beardy guy is the far right and what makes him so? followed the trail to esteemed Rupert Lowe MP - another multi-millionaire ex Reform guy.
I'm not sure what gives you the impression they have only just realised it. Even if they have it is more than I have heard from any british or American left wing pundit (I know of one swede) well, ever. Never mind the reasons for that in turn. Heck, most of them are full on magic money tree guys to this day.

I would be genuinely interested if you can recommend a left wing voice arguing against state borrowing and acknowledging the structural reasons underlying it. I would be positively taken aback, if you can refer me to one who joins the dots through our completely unsustainable social and sexual settlements, not to mention their beloved globalism.

That said I agree with you that there is nothing in this that we haven't done here years and years ago. I flagged it because of your previous interest in the right 'talking left', of which is it is an example - at least if you think these concerns the preserve of the left (which I don't). Although fwiw you have bailed before it was really discussed, which of course is fair enough - life is too short for 99.9% of Internet or any other media.

The beardy I am referring to is Carl Benjamin who is the middle of the three for most of it. Was a Dawkins type back in the day - that tribe under stress has seemingly either dyed their hair blue and and rejected reality entirely or stayed the course in rationalist fundamentalism, which becomes Western chauvinism as it becomes unavoidable that much of the world doesn't roll that way.

He is of the latter camp, though to be fair if your starting point is such a finger painted view of the world as the big haired evangelists of all that stuff bequeathed, there aren't many ways to go.
 
I'm not sure what gives you the impression they have only just realised it. Even if they have it is more than I have heard from any british or American left wing pundit (I know of one swede) well, ever. Never mind the reasons for that in turn. Heck, most of them are full on magic money tree guys to this day.

I would be genuinely interested if you can recommend a left wing voice arguing against state borrowing and acknowledging the structural reasons underlying it. I would be positively taken aback, if you can refer me to one who joins the dots through our completely unsustainable social and sexual settlements, not to mention their beloved globalism.

That said I agree with you that there is nothing in this that we haven't done here years and years ago. I flagged it because of your previous interest in the right 'talking left', of which is it is an example - at least if you think these concerns the preserve of the left (which I don't). Although fwiw you have bailed before it was really discussed, which of course is fair enough - life is too short for 99.9% of Internet or any other media.

The beardy I am referring to is Carl Benjamin who is the middle of the three for most of it. Was a Dawkins type back in the day - that tribe under stress has seemingly either dyed their hair blue and and rejected reality entirely or stayed the course in rationalist fundamentalism, which becomes Western chauvinism as it becomes unavoidable that much of the world doesn't roll that way.

He is of the latter camp, though to be fair if your starting point is such a finger painted view of the world as the big haired evangelists of all that stuff bequeathed, there aren't many ways to go.
you took from that the problem is state borrowing? the issue I think they were describing was much broader than that - it was the economic model itself? if its the latter try Stiglitz and Picketty for example on rent seeking if you're looking for something newer than Ricardo or Marx but dude this has been the bread and butter of every leftist thinker for 100s of years. I get there are and likely always have been conservatives who aren't admirers of (neo-)liberalism I'm not disputing that, Peter Hitchens has however seemed like a lone voice in the wilderness on the right until lately though. There has been no coherent and popular critique of capitalism and free markets from the right, or not any I have heard until the rise of national(ist) conservatism of folk like Oren Cass (and some (but by no means all) of the thinkers around Vance and Trump). The break with economic liberalism and market fundamentalism seems a new phenomena on the right (say since the 90's and my adulthood) in terms of its popular appeal. what would you like to discuss, didnt mean to bail?
 
you took from that the problem is state borrowing? the issue I think they were describing was much broader than that - it was the economic model itself? if its the latter try Stiglitz and Picketty for example on rent seeking if you're looking for something newer than Ricardo or Marx but dude this has been the bread and butter of every leftist thinker for 100s of years. I get there are and likely always have been conservatives who aren't admirers of (neo-)liberalism I'm not disputing that, Peter Hitchens has however seemed like a lone voice in the wilderness on the right until lately though. There has been no coherent and popular critique of capitalism and free markets from the right, or not any I have heard until the rise of national(ist) conservatism of folk like Oren Cass (and some (but by no means all) of the thinkers around Vance and Trump). The break with economic liberalism and market fundamentalism seems a new phenomena on the right (say since the 90's and my adulthood) in terms of its popular appeal. what would you like to discuss, didnt mean to bail?
Of course it's much broader than that, but most left wing pundits don't get past go, in that they want the borrowed money to keep flowing - and that's the 'front end' of the whole thing.

The collapse of a self sustaining society, the export of jobs / mass import of labour , and a mushrooming welfare bill these contribute too, produce western countries rooted in financialisation and rentierism. I have not seen any left wing pundit address this, I suspect because the welfarism, social liberalism and globalism they are wedded to are the central culprits, while in every day terms they want that free money to keep coming.

News to me that Ricardo is left wing, and Marx was talking about a different set of problems rooted in his times and now largely beside the point. Stiglitiz is AFAIK a big money / government guy and so is Picketty. They may (to their credit) worry about effects but to my knowledge - which granted is limited on Picketty in particular - they fight shy of causes. And that's the left wing achilles heel I mention : ultimate causes are bound up in things they support.

Finally there is nothing new in this. For instance Rerum Novarum, a much cited wellspring, predates publication of the final volume of Kapital, and is a response to both the same problems Marx was getting at, and to the socialist / communist alternative he was central to. The cold war and the struggle against communism funnelled (classical) liberals into Conservative parties and they became dominant - Thatcher in this country for instance, though Britain is not really a good example as it was also bust and it's conservativism rooted in the vagaries of the British class system. These contemporary tendencies, it seems to me, are about dispensing with that settlement.

That said, and as I have said previously many times, I am not convinced that traditions ranging from Christian Democracy to Distributism which came from historic conservatism (though the latter now mainly the preserve of the anarchist left) have answers to where we are now - comprehensive ones anyway. We need a new idea and noone has one.

At least the right are trying though: once more I haven't seen a prescription for action from the left that doesn't boil down to more of the same - more government spending and control - which is the 'managerial state' end product of all of it anyway, and why the centre left are quite happy with it in the end.

Ps I wasn't suggesting you were bailing on the topic but that you have turned off the vid before they really get into this. Which like I say I understand completely, and you won't get any answers from it just a demonstration of where concerns are on the right.
 
Last edited:
Of course it's much broader than that, but most left wing pundits don't get past go, in that they want the borrowed money to keep flowing - and that's the 'front end' of the whole thing.
it really isn't - while austerity might seem logical if you apply the household metaphor, when implemented by countries as we have seen in multiple places in the last 20 years, the collective reduction in spending has shrunk our economies, leading to lower tax revenues and higher debt-to-GDP ratios (despite being rhetorically aimed at delivering the opposite). it is a form of 'class politics' designed to reduce the power of normal folk and protect the 'elite', re-distributing wealth and resources toward creditors and the affluent. Its part of the problem not the solution and a political act not an economic necessity

The collapse of a self sustaining society, the export of jobs / mass import of labour , and a mushrooming welfare bill these contribute too, produce western countries rooted in financialisation and rentierism. I have not seen any left wing pundit address this, I suspect because the welfarism, social liberalism and globalism they are wedded to are the central culprits, while in every day terms they want that free money to keep coming.
a couple of things - i'm not so sure the left are wedded to social liberalism i'll give you there is a strong overlap in the post modern era but just as not all conservatives are market fundamentalists so too is there diversity of view on social issues on the left

globalism is not the same as internationalism - one seeks a capitalist market system, blurring borders for frictionless flow of goods and capital (people too sometimes), while the internationalism of the left focuses on cooperation and solidarity between distinct nations, fostering collaboration (treaties, alliances, cultural exchange). globalism is neo-imperialist, internationalism is anti-imperialist.

you cant blame the economic model of financialisation and rentierism on immigration or welfare or rather to do so isnt to understand the choices that have been made (sometimes with good intentions) - the link you provided was at least cogent enough to recognise these are not the drivers rather they are symptoms. Our economic model has been primarily produced by a shift in economic activity from production and innovation to the extraction of rent from the ownership of scarce assets driven by deliberate policy changes (e.g. permissive tax system, deregulation, privatisation, tolerance of monopolies etc) and market dynamics ( e.g. scarcity, cheap credit, the need for new markets)



News to me that Ricardo is left wing
yeah true - but there are roots in his work that were proto-left - labour theory of value etc

, and Marx was talking about a different set of problems rooted in his times and now largely beside the point. Stiglitiz is AFAIK a big money / government guy and so is Picketty. They may (to their credit) worry about effects but to my knowledge - which granted is limited on Picketty in particular - they fight shy of causes. And that's the left wing achilles heel I mention : ultimate causes are bound up in things they support.
I've been over causes above - think what you mean is they identify different causes to the ones you have mentioned
At least the right are trying though: once more I haven't seen a prescription for action from the left that doesn't boil down to more of the same - more government spending and control - which is the 'managerial state' end product of all of it anyway, and why the centre left are quite happy with it in the end.
I agree - that's exactly what I've said before. I'm wondering if the popular strain of analysis on the right - e.g. anti-war, multi-polar, anti-globalist, anti-market fundamentalist, pro-citizen/worker is opening a space where the left can rediscover some of its former energy....we do need better leaders/intellectuals than Polanski or Mamdani though - broadly the debate might focus on nationalism vs internationalism (vs globalism - possibly defeated by America first etc) the trick will be to help facilitate the end of globalism but provide a bulwark against the dangers of nationalism (we know where that can lead)
Ps I wasn't suggesting you were bailing on the topic but that you have turned off the vid before they really get into this. Which like I say I understand completely, and you won't get any answers from it just a demonstration of where concerns are on the right.
gotcha - cheers
 
it really isn't - while austerity might seem logical if you apply the household metaphor, when implemented by countries as we have seen in multiple places in the last 20 years, the collective reduction in spending has shrunk our economies, leading to lower tax revenues and higher debt-to-GDP ratios (despite being rhetorically aimed at delivering the opposite). it is a form of 'class politics' designed to reduce the power of normal folk and protect the 'elite', re-distributing wealth and resources toward creditors and the affluent. Its part of the problem not the solution and a political act not an economic necessity
Which countries?

Countries that underwent austerity are now on the up, such as Greece, not to mention Ireland, the world's richest country per head (setting aside wee statelets like Monaco). Britain never had austerity, all we did was slow the rate of increase of our borrowing.

I'd really love you to explain any of this. Even yon Gary economics will tell you that printing money funnels wealth upwards. I'm really struggling to figure out what you mean here... You want to keep borrowing but you don't want to serve creditors? Thats a contradiction in terms! More to the pointing we are eating our own tail now and charging towards a financial crisis.

Maybe you should go back to that vid, as they get into similar stuff.

Ps I'm not talking for or agin austerity to begin with but the much bigger picture from which it is one side effect.

a couple of things - i'm not so sure the left are wedded to social liberalism i'll give you there is a strong overlap in the post modern era but just as not all conservatives are market fundamentalists so too is there diversity of view on social issues on the left
Maybe so, but I'm talking about the left that influences the world. Everyone from Labour to YP in the UK.
globalism is not the same as internationalism - one seeks a capitalist market system, blurring borders for frictionless flow of goods and capital (people too sometimes), while the internationalism of the left focuses on cooperation and solidarity between distinct nations, fostering collaboration (treaties, alliances, cultural exchange). globalism is neo-imperialist, internationalism is anti-imperialist.
Yeah but today's left is wedded to globalism.
you cant blame the economic model of financialisation and rentierism on immigration or welfare or rather to do so isnt to understand the choices that have been made (sometimes with good intentions) - the link you provided was at least cogent enough to recognise these are not the drivers rather they are symptoms. Our economic model has been primarily produced by a shift in economic activity from production and innovation to the extraction of rent from the ownership of scarce assets driven by deliberate policy changes (e.g. permissive tax system, deregulation, privatisation, tolerance of monopolies etc) and market dynamics ( e.g. scarcity, cheap credit, the need for new markets)
Yes but why did Labour shift us to that? To fund the state, which is no longer fundable organically due to the increased demand and reduced supply engendered by social meltdown and the population crisis.

And financialisation is absolutely joined at the hip with globalism, rentierism too. There's no loot to be made from rent without a mismatch in supply and demand on housing, and that's a product of said social breakdown but also vast immigration. And yes also deliberate policy to fund the state.

As for financialisation - if you export all you jobs and buy back the products you leave new manufacturers swimming in sterling which needs managed - often to buy up our onshore assets. Flooding the country with borrowed money is similar in effect - and also makes buying up assets for rent highly attractive.

You talk of reversing cause and effect I fear it is you that are doing that. Why did Labour do these things and the tories follow suit? Why is Reeves upping the ante further?
yeah true - but there are roots in his work that were proto-left - labour theory of value etc
Which is nonsense on stilts
I've been over causes above - think what you mean is they identify different causes to the ones you have mentioned
No you haven't explained causes. You have talked about policy. Why was that policy formulated? That's causes.
I agree - that's exactly what I've said before. I'm wondering if the popular strain of analysis on the right - e.g. anti-war, multi-polar, anti-globalist, anti-market fundamentalist, pro-citizen/worker is opening a space where the left can rediscover some of its former energy....we do need better leaders/intellectuals than Polanski or Mamdani though - broadly the debate might focus on nationalism vs internationalism (vs globalism - possibly defeated by America first etc) the trick will be to help facilitate the end of globalism but provide a bulwark against the dangers of nationalism (we know where that can lead)
Internationalism has led to more disaster than nationalism. Much more.

We need to worry less about labels and focus on the problems of today and how we can respond to them. Globalism is at the heart of that and is empowering our adversaries while ravaging western societies - which were already going down the swanee at a clip. Internationalism of the day dream sort doesn't feature. China, Russia, South East Asia, the Islamic world don't give a fuck about such western fantasies.
gotcha - cheers
👍
 
Last edited:
Wow. So looking forward to this. Will be edgy as fuck. Orange Man bad. Hur, hur, hur.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I thought it was ch4's brief to provide alternative programming? If that was what they did once it has not been so for decades.

Perhaps they need to be reminded what alternative means ?
 
I thought it was ch4's brief to provide alternative programming? If that was what they did once it has not been so for decades.

Perhaps they need to be reminded what alternative means ?
What Graham Linehan accurately calls regime comedians.
 
Maybe. But don't you think Trump is worthy of criticism ?
Not in a Christmas message, 'alternative' or not, in Britain. Especially not from an American regime comedian.

I wonder if his theme will take in his own repugnant behaviour following the murder of Charlie Kirk, and indeed the fascism that gave rise to that murder?

Or perhaps current day persecution of the jews, two thousand years on, and the fascism that gives rise to that?

These things would be a little less clichéd and a lot more alternative, but its still not Christmas UK business, although the last is at least UK relevant.
 
Which countries?

Countries that underwent austerity are now on the up, such as Greece, not to mention Ireland, the world's richest country per head (setting aside wee statelets like Monaco). Britain never had austerity, all we did was slow the rate of increase of our borrowing.

I'd really love you to explain any of this. Even yon Gary economics will tell you that printing money funnels wealth upwards. I'm really struggling to figure out what you mean here... You want to keep borrowing but you don't want to serve creditors? Thats a contradiction in terms! More to the pointing we are eating our own tail now and charging towards a financial crisis.

Maybe you should go back to that vid, as they get into similar stuff.

Ps I'm not talking for or agin austerity to begin with but the much bigger picture from which it is one side effect.
my point here is only that borrowing isn't automatically 'bad' in itself in the way you appear to think it is - cutting spending while in an economic downturn can and has worsened debt by shrinking the economy (its called iirc the denominator effect). Incidentally I am not saying excessive or reckless borrowing is a good idea either.... and perhaps we (I) are conflating spending and borrowing too much - there are other tools in the box - if you're not for austerity what are you for out of interest?
Yes but why did Labour shift us to that? To fund the state, which is no longer fundable organically due to the increased demand and reduced supply engendered by social meltdown and the population crisis.
im more cynical than that but really I think there was a lot of going along and putting all bets on the City of London - when you say Labour are not the party of labour anymore we agree that they are the party of the technocratic elite - they are the beneficiaries of globalism (which you used to eulogise irrc)

Which is nonsense on stilts
I refer you again to the post 283 in quotes


No you haven't explained causes. You have talked about policy. Why was that policy formulated? That's causes.
fair to a point though policy isnt always reactive and thats what i meant - ideological choices

Internationalism has led to more disaster than nationalism. Much more.

We need to worry less about labels and focus on the problems of today and how we can respond to them. Globalism is at the heart of that and is empowering our adversaries while ravaging western societies - which were already going down the swanee at a clip. Internationalism of the day dream sort doesn't feature. China, Russia, South East Asia, the Islamic world don't give a fuck about such western fantasies.
is globalism not a label as well - jeez man sometimes short hand for broad concepts saves the thread length but given your first sentence above maybe i need to refer you to wiki again ;P seriously though I'm not as pessimistic as you are on the national darwinism vision you portray, there remains a strong sense of interdependence and solidarity but I'd agree the rise in nationalism is a concern.
 
my point here is only that borrowing isn't automatically 'bad' in itself in the way you appear to think it is - cutting spending while in an economic downturn can and has worsened debt by shrinking the economy (its called iirc the denominator effect). Incidentally I am not saying excessive or reckless borrowing is a good idea either.... and perhaps we (I) are conflating spending and borrowing too much - there are other tools in the box - if you're not for austerity what are you for out of interest?
Yes, this is Keynesian orthodoxy. Unfortunately new labour broke that by contra Keynes behaviour - ie taking on debt during the biggest boom in history when that was the time to pay it down and prepare for the next downturn. Happened across the world, and the model is now broken. And broken for far deeper reasons than that. It's spiralling out of control and there are no means to arrest it: in the UK's case not even inflation due to the structure of our gilts.

As for what I am for: I'm not talking about managing this car crash through policy within the failed model. I believe global capitalism is gubbed completely from a western perspective which is why for all it's many many ills, the hail Mary the US are attempting is something we should all be invested in. If they can't unpick the globalist machine then western labour is gubbed forever, or at least until the west becomes unrecognisable and the new 'poor world' .

But since you ask, within the status quo we need to grow revenues and reduce costs. So far so obvious but we need to follow through on what that means - reducing the cost of doing business on every axis bar wages, so energy cost, tax burden etc, and we need to vastly reduce state expenditure. Welfare needs to return to being a safety net, services need massive reform and in may cases downsizing.

I don't think it's achievable.
im more cynical than that but really I think there was a lot of going along and putting all bets on the City of London - when you say Labour are not the party of labour anymore we agree that they are the party of the technocratic elite - they are the beneficiaries of globalism (which you used to eulogise irrc)
When did I eulogise globalism? I said it has dragged much of the world out of absolute poverty. It has, and continues to do so. At the expense of western labour. You can use the site's search and you will find me saying the same things as far back as it goes - quite often to you!
I refer you again to the post 283 in quotes
I'm not particularly convinced that fits me, and I'm not talking about Sancho's intentions but the original author's. Few things are as daft as Marx's theory of Labour value. As has been proved to destruction. Quite literally. And not least by globalism.


fair to a point though policy isnt always reactive and thats what i meant - ideological choices
No it's not alway reactive. But it always has a motive and thats your cause.

Global capitalism and progressive leftism have long been converging on increasingly common goals which is why the parties are so similar
is globalism not a label as well - jeez man sometimes short hand for broad concepts saves the thread length but given your first sentence above maybe i need to refer you to wiki again ;P seriously though I'm not as pessimistic as you are on the national darwinism vision you portray, there remains a strong sense of interdependence and solidarity but I'd agree the rise in nationalism is a concern.
Sorry that's fair and poorly expressed by me. What I meant was that we shouldn't automatically reject or embrace things because of association with things to which the same label can be applied. Scottish nationalism is not 1930s German nationalism for instance.

The nation state - as opposed to belligerent nationalism - has been the only vehicle for democracy and remains the only probable one. It is also the viable alternative to empire which any international polity tends towards and has been tending that way again, albeit in a new form of unaccountable and increasingly undemocratic supra national bodies in symbiosis with multi national corporations. It is in the interests of both to dissolve national communities. How much those interests have influenced the reality of c21 and where policy, coincidence and conspiracy are demarked... well that's a whole topic.

The international project you refer to was wholly a western thing and could only be entertained in a colonial era and it's afterglow. It is a colonial project itself that takes as read that we can implant western ideals into the rest of the world whose cultural differences internationalists fail to respect, in typically colonialist style.

That moment has passed. The rest of the world are no longer our vassals, and have pretty much uniformly sloughed off imported western ideas and returned to their own inheritances. In parallel they are accelerating past us as we slip into decadence and certainly won't be entertaining the fantasies of a civilisation busy destroying itself.

We are heading for a multi polar world and it is no longer viable to cling to the idea that the west can convert all the brown, black and yellow people to it's wisdom. Even if only for selfish reasons the patrician supremacism of western progressivism needs confined to the bin.
 
Last edited:
Yes, this is Keynesian orthodoxy. Unfortunately new labour broke that by contra Keynes behaviour - ie taking on debt during the biggest boom in history when that was the time to pay it down and prepare for the next downturn. Happened across the world, and the model is now broken. And broken for far deeper reasons than that. It's spiralling out of control and there are no means to arrest it: in the UK's case not even inflation due to the structure of our gilts.

As for what I am for: I'm not talking about managing this car crash through policy within the failed model. I believe global capitalism is gubbed completely from a western perspective which is why for all it's many many ills, the hail Mary the US are attempting is something we should all be invested in. If they can't unpick the globalist machine then western labour is gubbed forever, or at least until the west becomes unrecognisable and the new 'poor world' .

But since you ask, within the status quo we need to grow revenues and reduce costs. So far so obvious but we need to follow through on what that means - reducing the cost of doing business on every axis bar wages, so energy cost, tax burden etc, and we need to vastly reduce state expenditure. Welfare needs to return to being a safety net, services need massive reform and in may cases downsizing.

no offence but the prescription just sounds like austerity plus, which imo would be a disaster for reasons already stated. I'm far from convinced that's what the Americans are going for which i think is more of a Christian nationalism. I do agree welfare reform is required but such is the mess we're in that will need to be gradualist and paternal if we're to avoid catastrophic consequences for society - I don't think we can do a clean sweep but we do need direction.

Sorry that's fair and poorly expressed by me. What I meant was that we shouldn't automatically reject or embrace things because of association with things to which the same label can be applied. Scottish nationalism is not 1930s German nationalism for instance.

cool I agree
the nation state - as opposed to belligerent nationalism - has been the only vehicle for democracy and remains the only probable one. It is also the viable alternative to empire which any international polity tends towards and has been tending that way again, albeit in a new form of unaccountable and increasingly undemocratic supra national bodies in symbiosis with multi national corporations. It is in the interests of both to dissolve national communities. How much those interests have influenced the reality of c21 and where policy, coincidence and conspiracy are demarked... well that's a whole topic.
If we agree nationalism can have both positive and negative traits and I can agree some versions can be anti-imperial even if inherently it is not always the case. I do agree the nation state (ideally imo federalised/decentralised) provides a useful framework for democracy to operate within - and that is valuable. what comes next is logically what should a modern nation state look like? for me - that's about citizenship, equality before the law (rights and duties defined in a constitution?), popular consent/democratic, based on principles of subsidiarity, communitarianism and solidarity (at the risk of knocking off Glasman ;P)
The international project you refer to was wholly a western thing and could only be entertained in a colonial era and it's afterglow. It is a colonial project itself that takes as read that we can implant western ideals into the rest of the world whose cultural differences internationalists fail to respect, in typically colonialist style.
I'd be against the idea we should implant western ideals in the manner you describe and I am instinctively wary of supranational unions, I too think there has to be a mechanism to foster cross national interdependence and co-operation. multilateralism if you will.
 
no offence but the prescription just sounds like austerity plus, which imo would be a disaster for reasons already stated. I'm far from convinced that's what the Americans are going for which i think is more of a Christian nationalism. I do agree welfare reform is required but such is the mess we're in that will need to be gradualist and paternal if we're to avoid catastrophic consequences for society - I don't think we can do a clean sweep but we do need direction.
Whatever they are doing or not doing re Christian Nationalism, from an economic point of view they are trying to bring jobs back to America. If they can't pull it off there is little hope for any other country.

On the austerity point, once more my theme is replacement of the status quo being required. But if we are going to assume the status quo - not least in the absence of alternatives being identified - then we absolutely need to reduce costs and raise revenues.

If we don't we will go bust and then we will find out what austerity is.
cool I agree

If we agree nationalism can have both positive and negative traits and I can agree some versions can be anti-imperial even if inherently it is not always the case. I do agree the nation state (ideally imo federalised/decentralised) provides a useful framework for democracy to operate within - and that is valuable. what comes next is logically what should a modern nation state look like? for me - that's about citizenship, equality before the law (rights and duties defined in a constitution?), popular consent/democratic, based on principles of subsidiarity, communitarianism and solidarity (at the risk of knocking off Glasman ;P)
Hang on, I thought you said his ideas where nostalgia items?! I agree subsidiarity would be a grand concept if it could be applied but I don't see how I can. I don't see how you don't get crushed by scale players.

The problem with the other things you mention is they require a cohesive society which we no longer have: one of many motives globalist advocates have to the dissolution of nations.
I'd be against the idea we should implant western ideals in the manner you describe and I am instinctively wary of supranational unions, I too think there has to be a mechanism to foster cross national interdependence and co-operation. multilateralism if you will.
What is the motive for China, India, Russia and others to do anything about a situation with where they gain at the expense of western labour?

Why would they make themselves dependent on other nations where they don't have to : especially ones that have gone mad - which in their eyes I expect europe has. What's in it for them?

We are the ones that are failing, they aren't
 

"Museums have hidden sculptures of naked males because they were designed for women’s eyes only.

Manchester Museum has ensured carved figures and other objects remain in storage and out of respect for African cultural taboos.

Part of the University of Manchester, the museum keeps wooden sculptures from public view because in their original cultural context, they were only intended to be viewed by women.

Sculptures depicting naked male figures, created by the Vai people of Liberia and Sierra Leone who have a range of female-only rituals, are kept out of sight.

Other objects intended for men’s eyes only are also hidden."


The very people that shred the basics a society needs to keep going defer to the concerns of bygone rain dancers.

Sometimes one can see the bright side in demographic replacement putting an end to this nonsense.