Funny you mention that EG. A wee while ago I did attempt to get some conversation flowing from the many 'wimmin protectors' on here, following the publishing of the second Angiolini report. Wanted to hear more on their thoughts, feelings and ideas around this passion they have to make life safer for women and girls, and the proposals within the report:
Been surprised there’s no thread on the Angiolini Inquiry findings yet, given how much chat theres been in this parish about women’s safety, and protection from sexual abuse. It's very much been a recurring theme, and is clearly an issue very close to a lot of hearts here..
Got some time on my hands so let's get the baw rolling. As you'd expect, this stuff is grim. Four years after part 1 first exposed the scale of police failures, part 2 shows how much still hasn’t been fixed. A few of the headline findings fae across both reports:
Catastrophic vetting failures and no consistent...
Alas, barring a couple of half-hearted attempts, it was tumbleweed. Seems this late-in-life desire to 'protect wimmin' is strictly segregated (pun intended) for them transgenders only. It does make one wonder
why though? What is it about transgender folk that triggers the boomers and gen x-ers so much, if its not
actually the reason they say it is?
I do have a theory. Maybe I'll pop that on a thread of its own one day; potentially more chance of traction..
I think you should post your 'theory'. It would be a good basis for debate.
As for the 'late in life' observation , surely that is a result of the issue as we understand now being a recent development? I remember when travelling there would be places where transvestites were not just tolerated but celebrated. Paddington in Sydney being a prime example. Drag was really popular. And very few people seemed to care about the Ladyboys of Bangkok annual visit to the Fringe.
So what changed? To my mind it was a politically driven move to shift people dressing or acting as the opposite sex to something more profound - that people actually changed sex. That's a pretty dramatic reframing of thousands of years of social relationships.
The tactics were a mix of stealth and aggression. People try to do the right thing as they see it, but with no debate mantra, how could it be questioned? And that was essential as there are key questions:
- what does trans actually mean?
- what exactly is non-binary?
- is two spirit really a thing?
But addressing these questions needed to be avoided because there is no broadly accepted answer.
Let's take self ID. If someone can sign a bit of paper to say they have changed sex, what has actually changed? The answer is we don't know. The spectrum goes from nothing right through to full physical transition. But if we take m to f transition, are we really saying that someone signs a piece of paper and does nothing else that they are a woman for all intents and purposes? Because if you agree with that then terms like 'lady penis' will cause you no concern at all.
But the next part needed to make this work was no challenge acceptance. And we've seen this play out in recent court cases and tribunals. This can only work if same sex spaces aren't same sex spaces. Unless you argue that a m to f trans person is actually a woman then the whole edifice collapses. You are saying that women who don't wish a biological man in same sex spaces has no right to object on any grounds: moral, religious or fear.
And this was promoted by politicians and campaign groups. Stonewall called lesbians who didn't want to have sex with trans men 'sexual racists'. Which flies in the face of everything about unpressured consent.
Why? I think garbled sense of trying to do the right thing coupled with limited space in the economic sphere to be 'progressive'.
Had the campaign had a little give and take, coupled with a sense that some people need boundaries, then I think there would be general acceptance. But there was no give and take.
That was bad enough, but the fatal error to my mind was kids. Pushing for a single response to confused kids - the affirmation approach with related physical and medical interventions is just wrong. And it happened. Just look up Mermaids. It's horrifying. And in many cases driven by rampant homophobia.
I suspect most people would say adults can do what they want, but kids? A step too far.
Do I care if people dress and act as the opposite sex? No. Do I care if people say they are the opposite sex and I have to agree and comply? Yes. Be it same sex care, single sex provision, sports and social on I think people have the right to organise along biological sex lines.
Feel free to make the argument why you thing I'm wrong.