How woke is too woke?

I saw an interesting discussion with Jacinda Ardern which touched on the internationalisation of rage politics. Social media absolutely drives this. The amplification of themes and talking points from abroad, particularly from the US, is a major factor in this. Recent examples include Charlie Kirk, a pretty minor figure in UK terms, but all over the 'Unite the kingdom' march. I've also seen apparently UK posters going on about Tylenol, which is barely known here.

For me this is less about over focusing on politics, but rather more material to feed the constant drum beat of rage. It's pretty effective , which is why it's pushed by foreign trolls who want to destabilise countries. It's also, in my view, anti-politics. It's not about the issues that directly affect people: housing, health, the economy, employment and so on. And maybe that's the point. 'They're eating the swans you know'!
A bit like BLM
 
I saw an interesting discussion with Jacinda Ardern which touched on the internationalisation of rage politics. Social media absolutely drives this. The amplification of themes and talking points from abroad, particularly from the US, is a major factor in this. Recent examples include Charlie Kirk, a pretty minor figure in UK terms, but all over the 'Unite the kingdom' march. I've also seen apparently UK posters going on about Tylenol, which is barely known here.

For me this is less about over focusing on politics, but rather more material to feed the constant drum beat of rage. It's pretty effective , which is why it's pushed by foreign trolls who want to destabilise countries. It's also, in my view, anti-politics. It's not about the issues that directly affect people: housing, health, the economy, employment and so on. And maybe that's the point. 'They're eating the swans you know'!

100% agree. The rage social media keeps feeding never looks at the issues which might actually help people and reduce the rage. Unfortunately clicks mainly come from anger posts and then drives the machine further. I've taken Tylenol regularly when in North America and the nonsense surrounding it is bananas. Yet another case of tangoman sputtering garbage and the media actually discussing his madness. Having been to Canada they don't seem to have the rage the west does and they are bemused why the US is behaving the way it is. Canada has big homeless issues the same as the US and here but does not have the bitterness and anger in the air. From what I saw they focus on what makes them happy and love their sport and their weed. Seems a good combo to me.🤣
 
BTW it is anti politics and is used to distract from the real issues and corruption going on. God knows how we reverse this but the way its going it could get very ugly.
 
What a strange and vaguely sinister article. The guardian goes to work tracing 'far right networks' out to undermine 'institutions of truth'. First of all theres not much far rightness on display, and I imagine they've provided some of the more choice things they found. A bit of conspiracy theory, a bit of speaking about Islam as the enlightened classes do about Christianity, is what is highlighted anyway. Somewhere short of the guardian in its pogrom stirring pomp, in short - though thankfully that is now moderated somewhat.

Secondly, no reflection on the somewhat obvious point that if they actually want to help here, they could consider turning themselves into an 'institution of truth' rather than a practioner of cover ups, circulator of conspiracy theory, truth distorting narratives and demonising rhetoric. The main reason for an erosion in trust in post truth media like the guardian is not because some spud on the internet says they are not playing with a straight bat, but because they don't play with a straight bat. You can't give a platform to Owen Jones, George Monbiot or Kehinde Andrews - or a few years back overt hate peddlers like Seumas Milne - while pumping out racism, conspiracy theory, magial thinking and 'othering' rhetoic, then expect to be taken seriously when you lay into some fanny on facebook.


Ps it would be interesting if they turned their AIs on the venomous swamp that is their comments section.
 
Last edited:
I suppose it depends on how far a person is to the right not to recognise things as being 'far' right.

And vice versa.
Or just sticking to established meanings (even if they were always questionable, because they could often just as well be called far left) rather than bracketing disdain for the tory and labour parties, or concern over migration etc as 'far right'.

Which is the guardian doing exactly what it complains of; indeed it was somewhat of a pioneer in the area and is a lot more influential than a disgruntled housewife.
 
The guardian has certainly lost it way but is no way as bad as the mail or the express. I have to admit some articles in the guardian are unreadable as writers tie themselves in knots trying to appease one or other focus groups. The independent probably the best of the British press and even they stray into both left and right wing ideology.
Labels are pointless as they depend on your own views. Unfortunately the immigration issue has been hijacked by the far right so folk with total reasonable grounds for concern are grouped in with these extremists.
 
The guardian has certainly lost it way but is no way as bad as the mail or the express. I have to admit some articles in the guardian are unreadable as writers tie themselves in knots trying to appease one or other focus groups. The independent probably the best of the British press and even they stray into both left and right wing ideology.
Labels are pointless as they depend on your own views. Unfortunately the immigration issue has been hijacked by the far right so folk with total reasonable grounds for concern are grouped in with these extremists.
Has it, or is that what we are told? For example tens of thousands were involved in peaceful migrant hotel protests for weeks and it was badly covered at all, unless a few bams - either far right and / or funded counter protesters - arrived to stir up trouble. I'd say this far right narrative is almost entirely invented, with the likes of the guardian at the forefront.
 
Follow the science! No, not that science! WTF is going on with the NHS. First legitimising trans nonsense, now incest is best apparently.

 
For a simple soul like me looking in from afar, it looks like there's no end to ways Britain can appease Islam. Why? Fear? Votes? The oft repeated line "it's not your country it's ours" will probably come much quicker than you think.
 
Follow the science! No, not that science! WTF is going on with the NHS. First legitimising trans nonsense, now incest is best apparently.

I looked on the HEE Genomics Education Programme and couldn't find anything about it. I searched their website and it said "No results were found for "cousin marriage"." It doesn't seem they're promoting it very well!

It could get a mention on their courses.

If teaching about it is an actual thing then I suppose its facing up to what is actually going on in this country.

And dare I say it such practices have been going on in the UK for generations to the point there's a village in Scotland where the medics are very concerned about ongoing defects in new borns through to the problems that arise in adulthood due to their breading habits 🤔
 
I looked on the HEE Genomics Education Programme and couldn't find anything about it. I searched their website and it said "No results were found for "cousin marriage"." It doesn't seem they're promoting it very well!

It could get a mention on their courses.

If teaching about it is an actual thing then I suppose its facing up to what is actually going on in this country.

And dare I say it such practices have been going on in the UK for generations to the point there's a village in Scotland where the medics are very concerned about ongoing defects in new borns through to the problems that arise in adulthood due to their breading habits 🤔
They've now taken it down, apparently.

 
Here be more to the story Sancho posted....


The Mail on Sunday uncovered a remarkable set of NHS guidance this weekend – from NHS England’s Genomics Education Programme website – that claimed first-cousin marriage is linked to “stronger extended family support systems and economic advantages”.

After the story broke, the NHS quickly junked the website and Health Secretary Wes Streeting has now called for an apology from the unit behind it…

A research presentation published by the NHS’s National Institute for Health Research – still online – recommends that healthcare staff should:

“Develop cultural competence in service delivery and cultural awareness training that focus on breaking down stereotypes and understanding consanguinity (and termination) from an Islamic perspective.”

 
Here be more to the story Sancho posted....


The Mail on Sunday uncovered a remarkable set of NHS guidance this weekend – from NHS England’s Genomics Education Programme website – that claimed first-cousin marriage is linked to “stronger extended family support systems and economic advantages”.

After the story broke, the NHS quickly junked the website and Health Secretary Wes Streeting has now called for an apology from the unit behind it…

A research presentation published by the NHS’s National Institute for Health Research – still online – recommends that healthcare staff should:

“Develop cultural competence in service delivery and cultural awareness training that focus on breaking down stereotypes and understanding consanguinity (and termination) from an Islamic perspective.”

It's part of a wider retreat from reason, Jimmy, if inconvenient facts get in the way of 'feelings' or 'cultural sensitivities'. I remember a wee while back a cancer charity getting pelters for 'fat shaming' because it had the audacity to point out that being overweight can be a contributory factor in developing certain types of cancers. So 'body positivity' is apparently more important than the risk of heart disease, circulatory problems, mobility issues, cancer and type 2 diabetes caused by obesity. I read several years ago about the percentage of the NHS budget dedicated to treating type 2 diabetes; an entirely preventable condition. It was staggering. Still, I'm sure the cost is worth it to not hurt anyone's feelings. 🙄
 
Apart from the obvious, one reason the NHS guidance was doubly bonkers, is their so called advantages amount to advocating the benefits of a clan system. Which is generaly a disaster for the parts of the world where ir still pertains, as well as being a massive obstacle to integration in a migrant context.

The not terribly aryan Matthew Syed provides insightful commentary on this point if anyone is interested in googling.
 
It's part of a wider retreat from reason, Jimmy, if inconvenient facts get in the way of 'feelings' or 'cultural sensitivities'. I remember a wee while back a cancer charity getting pelters for 'fat shaming' because it had the audacity to point out that being overweight can be a contributory factor in developing certain types of cancers. So 'body positivity' is apparently more important than the risk of heart disease, circulatory problems, mobility issues, cancer and type 2 diabetes caused by obesity. I read several years ago about the percentage of the NHS budget dedicated to treating type 2 diabetes; an entirely preventable condition. It was staggering. Still, I'm sure the cost is worth it to not hurt anyone's feelings. 🙄
Yup we live in a world of widely-amplified right-wing lies.
 
"authoritarian fascists are already coming for us too, and to see it being reflected here is just so sad."

That ones a belter to start with....
 
What are your favourite intolerant illiberal liberal fantasies?
- the evils of whiteness
- the unique evil of zionism
- identity politics
- critical theory
- the great fabric of lies supporting global capitalism (no suppression of wages etc)
- cultural imperialism - tying aid and investment to submission to woke mandates
- the inquisition against dissent from the above and other things

Statism, corporatism, authoritarianism, politics of identity. There used to be a word for that.
 
Last edited:
I read several years ago about the percentage of the NHS budget dedicated to treating type 2 diabetes; an entirely preventable condition. It was staggering. Still, I'm sure the cost is worth it to not hurt anyone's feelings. 🙄
No as a Type 2 for longer than your lifespan your ' totally preventable condition' is factually wrong Quelle Surprise. There are several inputs including Genetics. There are clear actions to mitigate contracting it like healthy eating and weight control but your last sentence is usual haughty shite which I'm sure that your thumbs up right wing mentor will come along soon after Dr Googling.

BIG G
 
- the evils of whiteness
- the unique evil of zionism
- identity politics
- critical theory
- the great fabric of lies supporting global capitalism (no suppression of wages etc)
- cultural imperialism - tying aid and investment to submission to woke mandates
- the inquisition against dissent from the above and other things

Statism, corporatism, authoritarianism, politics of identity. There used to be a word for that.
I fucking love how you inevitably jump in Martin to answer a question posed to someone else! Do you thing that the persons asked are not up to answering?

BIG G
 
No as a Type 2 for longer than your lifespan your ' totally preventable condition' is factually wrong Quelle Surprise. There are several inputs including Genetics. There are clear actions to mitigate contracting it like healthy eating and weight control but your last sentence is usual haughty shite which I'm sure that your thumbs up right wing mentor will come along soon after Dr Googling.

BIG G
Harsh but fair.
 
No as a Type 2 for longer than your lifespan your ' totally preventable condition' is factually wrong Quelle Surprise. There are several inputs including Genetics. There are clear actions to mitigate contracting it like healthy eating and weight control but your last sentence is usual haughty shite which I'm sure that your thumbs up right wing mentor will come along soon after Dr Googling.

BIG G
OK then. I'll replace the word entirely with mostly if you want to be pedantic.

"Why are cases of diabetes growing so much?
Growing levels of obesity are fuelling an epidemic in type 2 diabetes. According to the World Obesity Federation, nearly 1 billion adults and 159 million children are living with obesity. As you are more likely to develop diabetes as you get older, an ageing global society is also increasing the prevalence of the condition. A healthy lifestyle is unaffordable for some people. In many countries, unhealthy food is cheap, convenient and heavily advertised, while healthy food can be increasingly difficult to get and more expensive in the face of the droughts, floods and rising seas caused by climate change, according to the World Health Organization. Meanwhile, in some places, it is difficult to exercise safely."

Guardian, November 13, 2024.

Strange how I have several family members and work colleagues who all developed type 2 diabetes as a direct result of poor diet and lack of exercise and have managed it by addressing those issues. But you crack on being rude and patronising to strangers on the Internet, about whom you know nothing, if it makes you feel morally superior.
 
Yep.

When are you marching on to halfwit house down in Holyrood then to overthrow the government?

I might join you if I'm no doing anything that day.
I'm more likely to get involved in a movement that celebrates human decency, mutual respect, celebrates diversity and promotes free love.

See you there! 🍻