Match Preview Hibs v Gunts

Purple & Green

Radge McRadge
Private Member
Admin
Joined
Jun 27, 2002
"At times I almost dream
I too have spent a life the sages' way,
And tread once more familiar paths. Perchance
I perished in an arrogant self-reliance
An age ago; and in that act, a prayer
For one more chance went up so earnest, so
Instinct with better light let in by Death,
That life was blotted out — not so completely
But scattered wrecks enough of it remain,
Dim memories; as now, when seems once more
The goal in sight again."

It's time to re acquaint ourselves with our cardigan wearing, Rover driving, bungalow dwelling, Billy Boys singing, Onion Jack waving, scarf birling fuds from Gorgie and surrounds. We've obviously already met them this season in a game that we were slow to get going, and then shot ourselves in the foot when we were in the ascendancy and looked to be getting back into the game. So there's an easy two things for Sunday - firstly don't start slowly and secondly no pointless indiscipline.

I know there is still a lot of hyperbole about how bad this Hibs team is; I don't have that view and I don't think it's borne out by stats. We may have been frustrated last night with the result, but I think there are large chunks of games we're performing well and our league position belies our quality. I do think though we struggle in some key aspects of games - particularly in the attacking final third and we don't score the goals we should - and I wouldn't disagree with anyone who says thats squarely down to bad recruitment. We need some rebalancing in January that should have been done in July, but we are where we are and it only takes a couple of big moments to go our way on Sunday for the result to follow on.

I'm sure we're all frustrated that there was no new manager bounce straight off in terms of results, but I think I can see a game by game improvement as the new manager starts to put his tactics and strategy in place. If I were him, I'd be working on the issues that have seen us concede two own goals in as many games. That needs fixed, but could be as simple as the team taking time to adapt to new instructions.

Our neighbours have benefitted from some fine sporting margins this season and are having to manage a European campaign as well as a league campaign. I think I read they've still to win a game in Europe this season. Scratch under the surface of their results and you find an interesting paradox: They are the top form team at home this season, but their away form is patchy and in fact worse than ours so far. Their win last weekend at Motherwell was their first victory outwith Edinburgh for several months. A team that is still working out how to play on the road?

They have a considerable injury list - much like ourselves - and some of those players will be a sore miss for them. Players to watch out for are top scores Calvin Miller and Claudia Braga while Jamie McCart is a cornerstone in their defence.

What of Hibs though, what can we expect? Well I think we can see the plan and the personnel

With that in mind, I think we might see this:
lineup-builder-3.png
The manager has had the games now he has to come up with the plan. I think a lot will depend on who is fit, I've assumed Starman will make it, I think this is the type of game that will suit him down to the ground.

I think Cadden and Newell have played their way into the team, even if Cadden's crosses would be much more suited to a bigger centre forward. Elding is an easy pick at centre forward, and he should cause Hearts problems. I suspect Mulligan will play, but I also think he's the most likely to make way if we have a better option on the right. Klidge might have been an option there but I feel he's failed to impress the manager.

It's surprising that Hanley hasn't been more involved, it's not that long ago since he did a fine job at the biggest competition of them all.

I'm looking forward to Sunday, travelling there with my youngest two who are well up for it. I hope the team are as well.

So that's my view, I'm much more interested in hearing yours

Hibernian Forever
 
Last edited:
I just can't see Mulligan being benched which gives us a headache. If I'm right Jordan Obita may be back in contention though I could be wrong about that. If he is I'd go for something like this

Elding (needs to slow his game down a bit)
McGrath
Chaiwa
Mayor Newell Mulligan
Obita Ivezic Kerr Passlack
Smith

Admittedly Sallinger made a couple of excellent stops last night but some of his kicking was atrocious. I also just think that historically we seem to have played better with Smudge in goal.
 
We’re going into this game in dreadful form, both overall and our recent record against them.

I think this Hibs team has had more of the ball under Reedjik but we continue to be incredibly poor in both boxes and that is where football matches are won or lost, not through nice possession stats or xG.

Hearts have plenty of attacking threat and quality, I do think they are pretty poor at the back… that’s where the opportunity to win this is.

The last time I can recall going into a derby with such little enthusiasm, with no element of hope other than avoiding an absolutely pumping, was an injury ravaged trip to Tynecastle where Derek Riordan scored the only goal of the game… can only hope for such an out of nowhere result this weekend.

My team would be:
Sallinger
Passlack Hanley Ivezic Mayor
Mulligan Chaiwa Newell Cadden
Elding Boyle
 
We’re going into this game in dreadful form, both overall and our recent record against them.

I think this Hibs team has had more of the ball under Reedjik but we continue to be incredibly poor in both boxes and that is where football matches are won or lost, not through nice possession stats or xG.

Hearts have plenty of attacking threat and quality, I do think they are pretty poor at the back… that’s where the opportunity to win this is.

The last time I can recall going into a derby with such little enthusiasm, with no element of hope other than avoiding an absolutely pumping, was an injury ravaged trip to Tynecastle where Derek Riordan scored the only goal of the game… can only hope for such an out of nowhere result this weekend.

My team would be:
Sallinger
Passlack Hanley Ivezic Mayor
Mulligan Chaiwa Newell Cadden
Elding Boyle
I’d go for that . McGrath was literally non existent, again . High tempo and workrate does not suit. For a senior player we need him to grab games by scruff of the kneck .

Hopefully, Boyley is fit to start and plays up front with Elden .
 
Last edited:
"At times I almost dream
I too have spent a life the sages' way,
And tread once more familiar paths. Perchance
I perished in an arrogant self-reliance
An age ago; and in that act, a prayer
For one more chance went up so earnest, so
Instinct with better light let in by Death,
That life was blotted out — not so completely
But scattered wrecks enough of it remain,
Dim memories; as now, when seems once more
The goal in sight again."

It's time to re acquaint ourselves with our cardigan wearing, Rover driving, bungalow dwelling, Billy Boys singing, Onion Jack waving, scarf birling fuds from Gorgie and surrounds. We've obviously already met them this season in a game that we were slow to get going, and then shot ourselves in the foot when we were in the ascendancy and looked to be getting back into the game. So there's an easy two things for Sunday - firstly don't start slowly and secondly no pointless indiscipline.

I know there is still a lot of hyperbole about how bad this Hibs team is; I don't have that view and I don't think it's borne out by stats. We may have been frustrated last night with the result, but I think there are large chunks of games we're performing well and our league position belies our quality. I do think though we struggle in some key aspects of games - particularly in the attacking final third and we don't score the goals we should - and I wouldn't disagree with anyone who says thats squarely down to bad recruitment. We need some rebalancing in January that should have been done in July, but we are where we are and it only takes a couple of big moments to go our way on Sunday for the result to follow on.

I'm sure we're all frustrated that there was no new manager bounce straight off in terms of results, but I think I can see a game by game improvement as the new manager starts to put his tactics and strategy in place. If I were him, I'd be working on the issues that have seen us concede two own goals in as many games. That needs fixed, but could be as simple as the team taking time to adapt to new instructions.

Our neighbours have benefitted from some fine sporting margins this season and are having to manage a European campaign as well as a league campaign. I think I read they've still to win a game in Europe this season. Scratch under the surface of their results and you find an interesting paradox: They are the top form team at home this season, but their away form is patchy and in fact worse than ours so far. Their win last weekend at Motherwell was their first victory outwith Edinburgh for several months. A team that is still working out how to play on the road?

They have a considerable injury list - much like ourselves - and some of those players will be a sore miss for them. Players to watch out for are top scores Calvin Miller and Claudia Braga while Jamie McCart is a cornerstone in their defence.

What of Hibs though, what can we expect? Well I think we can see the plan and the personnel

With that in mind, I think we might see this:
View attachment 22976
The manager has had the games now he has to come up with the plan. I think a lot will depend on who is fit, I've assumed Starman will make it, I think this is the type of game that will suit him down to the ground.

I think Cadden and Newell have played their way into the team, even if Cadden's crosses would be much more suited to a bigger centre forward. Elding is an easy pick at centre forward, and he should cause Hearts problems. I suspect Mulligan will play, but I also think he's the most likely to make way if we have a better option on the right. Klidge might have been an option there but I feel he's failed to impress the manager.

It's surprising that Hanley hasn't been more involved, it's not that long ago since he did a fine job at the biggest competition of them all.

I'm looking forward to Sunday, travelling there with my youngest two who are well up for it. I hope the team are as well.

So that's my view, I'm much more interested in hearing yours

Hibernian Forever
Agree with that team except I’d have Smith in goals. We’ve conceded loads from crosses and set pieces and it’s a Gunt speciality. At least Smith comes for crosses. I think we’re getting pumped regardless, but I’d like to see the self-inflicted stuff kept to a minimum if possible
 
Hibs were the better team by quite a bit last night.
Cadden and Passlack got in a few crosses , but when they looked up for someone to aim for.....
The defence is far from watertight, but if we could score at the other end it would help greatly!
 
Thanks @Purple & Green, I like your positivity, it's bigger than mine. I have the fear, expect the worst, hope for the best. I reckon our chances are are no better than 60/40. But chance we have and chances we will get.
Put it this way, I will have a great day beforehand and see what comes. I'm looking forward to it.
I would have your team but swap Hanley for Kerr.
Let's get behind them.lads. 💚
 
"At times I almost dream
I too have spent a life the sages' way,
And tread once more familiar paths. Perchance
I perished in an arrogant self-reliance
An age ago; and in that act, a prayer
For one more chance went up so earnest, so
Instinct with better light let in by Death,
That life was blotted out — not so completely
But scattered wrecks enough of it remain,
Dim memories; as now, when seems once more
The goal in sight again."

It's time to re acquaint ourselves with our cardigan wearing, Rover driving, bungalow dwelling, Billy Boys singing, Onion Jack waving, scarf birling fuds from Gorgie and surrounds. We've obviously already met them this season in a game that we were slow to get going, and then shot ourselves in the foot when we were in the ascendancy and looked to be getting back into the game. So there's an easy two things for Sunday - firstly don't start slowly and secondly no pointless indiscipline.

I know there is still a lot of hyperbole about how bad this Hibs team is; I don't have that view and I don't think it's borne out by stats. We may have been frustrated last night with the result, but I think there are large chunks of games we're performing well and our league position belies our quality. I do think though we struggle in some key aspects of games - particularly in the attacking final third and we don't score the goals we should - and I wouldn't disagree with anyone who says thats squarely down to bad recruitment. We need some rebalancing in January that should have been done in July, but we are where we are and it only takes a couple of big moments to go our way on Sunday for the result to follow on.

I'm sure we're all frustrated that there was no new manager bounce straight off in terms of results, but I think I can see a game by game improvement as the new manager starts to put his tactics and strategy in place. If I were him, I'd be working on the issues that have seen us concede two own goals in as many games. That needs fixed, but could be as simple as the team taking time to adapt to new instructions.

Our neighbours have benefitted from some fine sporting margins this season and are having to manage a European campaign as well as a league campaign. I think I read they've still to win a game in Europe this season. Scratch under the surface of their results and you find an interesting paradox: They are the top form team at home this season, but their away form is patchy and in fact worse than ours so far. Their win last weekend at Motherwell was their first victory outwith Edinburgh for several months. A team that is still working out how to play on the road?

They have a considerable injury list - much like ourselves - and some of those players will be a sore miss for them. Players to watch out for are top scores Calvin Miller and Claudia Braga while Jamie McCart is a cornerstone in their defence.

What of Hibs though, what can we expect? Well I think we can see the plan and the personnel

With that in mind, I think we might see this:
View attachment 22976
The manager has had the games now he has to come up with the plan. I think a lot will depend on who is fit, I've assumed Starman will make it, I think this is the type of game that will suit him down to the ground.

I think Cadden and Newell have played their way into the team, even if Cadden's crosses would be much more suited to a bigger centre forward. Elding is an easy pick at centre forward, and he should cause Hearts problems. I suspect Mulligan will play, but I also think he's the most likely to make way if we have a better option on the right. Klidge might have been an option there but I feel he's failed to impress the manager.

It's surprising that Hanley hasn't been more involved, it's not that long ago since he did a fine job at the biggest competition of them all.

I'm looking forward to Sunday, travelling there with my youngest two who are well up for it. I hope the team are as well.

So that's my view, I'm much more interested in hearing yours

Hibernian Forever

That team but Kerr out and Hanley in for me.

I'm not going on Sunday as it's the wedding anniversary and the Mrs is more appealing than Hibs at the minute.

I'll be delighted if I end up missing an all timer of a derby win. I'm thinking that's highly unlikely though.
 
Last edited:
Hibs were the better team by quite a bit last night.
Cadden and Passlack got in a few crosses , but when they looked up for someone to aim for.....
The defence is far from watertight, but if we could score at the other end it would help greatly!
Agreed. It’s all very well getting crosses in from wide areas but we need a bully boy to get on the end of them. I don’t think we’re a basket case yet but Reedijk needs some of our injured players back to give him some options. Too many off-form players at the same time. For me, Newell showed them the way last night and should be the first name on the team sheet for Sunday.
 
We weren’t dreadful last night. The consensus of the support at the game last night, was it was the best we’ve played under the new manager
Can’t wait for Sunday to come around
I thought we were dreadful in the first half, second half was a lot better. I thought imo we played better v the soapies
 
We concede too many silly goals, dont keep clean sheets and cant score enough goals, looks rather ominous to me.
 
Bit of a generalisation but it seems like there is a big disconnect between those who watched the match last night on tv and those who were actually there. Sometimes you just cant get the full picture from watching a fraction of the action so this has cheered me up a bit and given me a wee bit of hope for Sunday. I thought Mulligan was again limited with the ball but there is no doubt he was getting more stuck in. Need the whole team to battle on Sunday, no reason we can't do that as a minimum, and sounds like MR is moving the team in that direction.
 
I have the fear for Sunday and hate saying it. Our defence is awful, whilst they have Miller, Braga and McPake up front. We cant defend crosses or score goals.
I dont blame the manager for our failings, thats down to MM and his recruitment cohorts
 
"At times I almost dream
I too have spent a life the sages' way,
And tread once more familiar paths. Perchance
I perished in an arrogant self-reliance
An age ago; and in that act, a prayer
For one more chance went up so earnest, so
Instinct with better light let in by Death,
That life was blotted out — not so completely
But scattered wrecks enough of it remain,
Dim memories; as now, when seems once more
The goal in sight again."

It's time to re acquaint ourselves with our cardigan wearing, Rover driving, bungalow dwelling, Billy Boys singing, Onion Jack waving, scarf birling fuds from Gorgie and surrounds. We've obviously already met them this season in a game that we were slow to get going, and then shot ourselves in the foot when we were in the ascendancy and looked to be getting back into the game. So there's an easy two things for Sunday - firstly don't start slowly and secondly no pointless indiscipline.

I know there is still a lot of hyperbole about how bad this Hibs team is; I don't have that view and I don't think it's borne out by stats. We may have been frustrated last night with the result, but I think there are large chunks of games we're performing well and our league position belies our quality. I do think though we struggle in some key aspects of games - particularly in the attacking final third and we don't score the goals we should - and I wouldn't disagree with anyone who says thats squarely down to bad recruitment. We need some rebalancing in January that should have been done in July, but we are where we are and it only takes a couple of big moments to go our way on Sunday for the result to follow on.

I'm sure we're all frustrated that there was no new manager bounce straight off in terms of results, but I think I can see a game by game improvement as the new manager starts to put his tactics and strategy in place. If I were him, I'd be working on the issues that have seen us concede two own goals in as many games. That needs fixed, but could be as simple as the team taking time to adapt to new instructions.

Our neighbours have benefitted from some fine sporting margins this season and are having to manage a European campaign as well as a league campaign. I think I read they've still to win a game in Europe this season. Scratch under the surface of their results and you find an interesting paradox: They are the top form team at home this season, but their away form is patchy and in fact worse than ours so far. Their win last weekend at Motherwell was their first victory outwith Edinburgh for several months. A team that is still working out how to play on the road?

They have a considerable injury list - much like ourselves - and some of those players will be a sore miss for them. Players to watch out for are top scores Calvin Miller and Claudia Braga while Jamie McCart is a cornerstone in their defence.

What of Hibs though, what can we expect? Well I think we can see the plan and the personnel

With that in mind, I think we might see this:
View attachment 22976
The manager has had the games now he has to come up with the plan. I think a lot will depend on who is fit, I've assumed Starman will make it, I think this is the type of game that will suit him down to the ground.

I think Cadden and Newell have played their way into the team, even if Cadden's crosses would be much more suited to a bigger centre forward. Elding is an easy pick at centre forward, and he should cause Hearts problems. I suspect Mulligan will play, but I also think he's the most likely to make way if we have a better option on the right. Klidge might have been an option there but I feel he's failed to impress the manager.

It's surprising that Hanley hasn't been more involved, it's not that long ago since he did a fine job at the biggest competition of them all.

I'm looking forward to Sunday, travelling there with my youngest two who are well up for it. I hope the team are as well.

So that's my view, I'm much more interested in hearing yours

Hibernian Forever
Apart from dropping Kerr for Hanley, I would be okay with that team. Kerr is joint 2nd equal goalscorer this season with 2 goals, albeit at the wrong end.
 
Hearts big favourites, but as the song says,...i've gotta feeling.
Will be a bonus if Martin Boyle is fit to play, he's still our best bet for a goal.
Hibs have far too many players out injured or ill, and we are still trying to re-adjust mid-season to a new managers way of playing.
It's a one-off game though, and as I mentioned on another thread, I think Hibs can nick it.
 
Keep our discipline.Its a one off game.
Will need to defend better within the box.
Passlack really needs to concentrate on his defending.
He got ripped up a few times in last game.
Hanley for Kerr definitely.
Hopefully don’t lose a cheap goal in first 20 mins.

I think it will be 16 team game with hopefully our subs making an impact in the game.

GGTTH
 
Apart from dropping Kerr for Hanley, I would be okay with that team. Kerr is joint 2nd equal goalscorer this season with 2 goals, albeit at the wrong end.
If you’re a Hibs player, this is the kind of game you signed up for. Semi final at the national stadium against your greatest rivals, huge crowd etc.
If anyone can’t turn up for that they should sacked. Nerves, maybe, but leave them for the supporters. Just get out there and smash them, without getting booked or injured. It’s doable.
However Hearts players are in the same situation and alway raise their game against us. It’s the most important thing in their pathetic little lives. So, I think this time they will be a bit complacent. That’s what we must exploit. Go for it Hibs.
 
The Professor disnae have many good options but Newell must have played his way back into the team and Boyler always starts against Puddledrinkers if fit.✅️

Klidge wide left has failed against the weaker teams in the league so its not going to work against Puddledrinkers so hopefully that experiment is ditched and while there was no harm in giving it a go, it looks like SDG had Klidge sussed from the very start.🤔.

Defenders are the big call but Kerr for all his faults still looks quicker than Hanley to match the nippy speed threat of the Puddledrinkers attack.

"The Professor's" PHD cannae possibly have prepared him for this sort of match but he is very capable of doing something incredibly left field in either team selection or bringing on the Rubadubdubs.

Thats an option as for all his fancy talk nothing much has practically worked in the league campaign so far🤔

Blind hope beats any logical thought process in any cup semi v Puddledrinkers at Hampden so 1:0 to the good guys sneaking it in the last 5 minutes.🙏🙏
 
We have played the gunts at Hampden four times and had players sent off in three of them. Keeping our discipline is vital. Passlack is a worry if he starts getting turned inside out by McPake
 
Last edited:
We have played the gunts at Hampden four times and had players sent off in three of them. Keep our discipline is vital. Passlack is a worry if he starts getting turned inside out by McPake

Think we need to make McPake and Miller turn onto the backfoot to render them ineffective.

That will only come about with 11 players and better quality, swifter passing.

We def have the ability but have we got the belief and the luck?.
 
We have played the gunts at Hampden four times and had players sent off in three of them. Keeping our discipline is vital. Passlack is a worry if he starts getting turned inside out by McPake
Passlack is a huge concern. I don't trust his discipline after the split derby last season.
 
Passlack is a huge concern. I don't trust his discipline after the split derby last season.
Hopefully getting the armband will lead to a calmer and more responsible on-field approach.
Pretty sure he will get targeted by the Gunts, both for defensive frailties and temperament.

He should have the experience to deal with the latter at least.