Just back.....to reality

Oh well, here goes😠
Met up with a couple of pals pre match few beers all confident with our new found belief.We were all smugly saying how a team in form picks itself.😞
Didn't take long before that was quashed.
The game had hardly started before we were a goal down. The writing is on the wall I suppose when you save a pen but still lose a goal.
But, hey, we are strong enough to come back from early setbacks, so no real worries.
Not!
I thought for the next 20 minutes we looked promising, it was only a matter of time till we got back square
Not
Some wee tangerine prick flashed a header into our net while the Hibs defence looked awfy static. It was really game over.
HT
We didn't come out all blazing and very soon we were 3 doon. Then 4, and the guy driving said "I'm away Neil, it's your shout" I followed him out🤮.
So I don't know what happened from then, much the same I would confidentiality predict.
I won't mark the players individually, they were all a bit meeeeh. I will focus on what little positives I can find. I wouldn't lack them for effort, and today just wasn't our day. Let's be honest, we could have been 2 down at Hampden and at the sheep before we got the rub and done what Utd did to us today.
On them, they looked good, their no,16 stood out, playing as a 10 We showed the lack of quality which has haunted us all season.
I did think the fans were nervous and expectant today, some of the stick handed out is uncalled for and counter productive.
The team, and manager will now have to pull together and show us what they are really about.
I live in hope
God bless the Hibs
Excellent Mac just a pity you weren’t given something positive to report on.
 
The manager can't and certainly shouldn't make decisions at HT based on what happened at Aberdeen. He needs to make them based on what happened today in the first half. That he didn't is hugely concerning for me.
Well maybe he thought he'd fielded our strongest team in the right formation to deal with United but it was the application of our players and not the set up that was wrong.
Give them a bollocking at HT send them back out for 10 minutes and if they don't perform start hooking them. I've no problem with that, that's my view but I'm no manager.
 
Well maybe he thought he'd fielded our strongest team in the right formation to deal with United but it was the application of our players and not the set up that was wrong.
Give them a bollocking at HT send them back out for 10 minutes and if they don't perform start hooking them. I've no problem with that, that's my view but I'm no manager.
I once listened to an interview with Terry Christie and he said it's cowardice from any manager who doesn't change things at half time following a poor first half. The time to make the changes properly is at half time. Making changes to personnel at half time sends a stronger message than any bollocking IMO. That said Dundee United just looked like they had much better players than us all over the park. They looked like a proper team.
 
I once listened to an interview with Terry Christie and he said it's cowardice from any manager who doesn't change things at half time following a poor first half. The time to make the changes properly is at half time. Making changes to personnel at half time sends a stronger message than any bollocking IMO. That said Dundee United just looked like they had much better players than us all over the park. They looked like a proper team.
Who knows mate 3 of the subs against Aberdeen scored so yeah but how often does that happen. Not saying you're wrong or right just saying it doesn’t concern me as much in not making them at HT.
Like in my post still not sure what happened yesterday, a lot of players didn't seem to show for the ball like they were lacking in confidence again but off the back of 2 wins no matters the calibre of the opponents you think they'd be more hungry for a victory. 🤷‍♂️
 
Yesterday reminded me of a game in the late 80s August when we were 4-0 down to Dundee at half time. Wasn’t a bad Hibs team and Dundee with Wright and Coyle ran riot.

It happens sometimes.

I think on reflection though giving up a penalty after five mins and then a goal just before half time is rank bad game management. Not changing things at half time was more bad management.

Dundee United are nothing special but have had a sign over us last two games.

The conundrum hasn’t changed with a new formation and a new manager, we’re still struggling to get our next 11 players on the pitch in the best formation with the best tactics primarily because the squad is imbalanced with glaring gaps in key positions.
 
This is a massive window coming up in January, and the manager needs to be strong. He’s not the one responsible for the recruitment decisions - there’s a team in place that are all culpable.

If the window is another failure then yes by all means make those accountable for failure. FFS don’t change the manager just to hide the heat from those culpable.
 
V the Puddledrinkers was as fine a tactical masterclass from the manager in a high pressure game as you are likely to see.👏👏✅️

The game plan was executed precisely by motivated and focused players and I never bought in for one minute the Puddledrinkers whinges about "sicknote central" as there "Raison d'etre' has always been to win derby matches at any cost.

V Sheep, all you can do is beat what is in front of you and thats exactly what Hibs comprehensively achieved against Sheepies who had chucked it just as they had before a few years back in the 6:0 game ironically against "Badloss".

My observations of our manager is that he is fresh, exciting with smart ideas but his preperation is all about his tactics, his team, how he motivates his players and how his team should set up.

All very well but if he wants to bring any long term success which in my mind is 3rd place and European football then he needs to learn more about Scottish football and understand and stop opposing teams from playing to their strengths.

That was something Jack Ross and SDG for all there other faults had down to perfection and why they both turned out to be the "best of the rest" of a rather unimpressive plethora of managers since Mowbray 20 years ago with a shout out to Lennon who was a breath of fresh air for a while but only ever managed 4th.
Thank you sir.

We can all hope he does indeed get to grips with the teams here. Got to think he will, considering how key a part it plays, and his own approach, mindset, experience.

Interesting what you said about SDG - I often thought he didn't adapt us to opposition as much as as he should've. Seemed to stick to his system very rigidly.
 
This is a massive window coming up in January, and the manager needs to be strong. He’s not the one responsible for the recruitment decisions - there’s a team in place that are all culpable.

If the window is another failure then yes by all means make those accountable for failure. FFS don’t change the manager just to hide the heat from those culpable.

The same recruitment team are going to try and right their wrongs from the summer window in January, same as they did last summer. There’s zero accountability for the business they do, unless of course we end up relegated.

It’s early days but I’m convinced Reedijk is up to the job at all, a good talker full of buzzwords (we know the Gordon’s love that) but like many young / inexperienced coaches he seems welded to a single tactical approach and can’t change. Jim Goodwin had that sussed, an even worse sign is John McGlynn had that sussed in Reedijk’s second game.

All seems a bit doom and gloom, but I think the Hearts & Aberdeen games were outliers, and the rest of the performances - the inability to defend as a unit, that teams can easily cut us open with one pass, the inability to press as a collective, no patterns of play to give the player on the ball a forward option, not enough players in the box when we do get forward - are a reflection of where we are. The change of manager has had no impact.
 
It’s early days but I’m convinced Reedijk is up to the job at all, a good talker full of buzzwords (we know the Gordon’s love that) but like many young / inexperienced coaches he seems welded to a single tactical approach and can’t change. Jim Goodwin had that sussed, an even worse sign is John McGlynn had that sussed in Reedijk’s second game.
Think this is still a bit hasty even with the qualifier. Regardless of how early results go, it usually takes a period of consistency for a manager's tactical instructions to bed in, and while some coaches can keep it simple and play five formations in their first five matches, that's not necessarily flexibility so much as shallowness.

Fundamentally I don't think the problem is being wedded to one tactic, it's that with our injuries at the back, poor recruitment up front, and multiple players out of form in the midfield, we're not really equipped for anything SDG or Reedijk have been trying to achieve. Jim Goodwin couldn't outthink Ryan69 ffs, he's not sussed anything, he just had a team in good rhythm vs one distinctly not
 
Think this is still a bit hasty even with the qualifier. Regardless of how early results go, it usually takes a period of consistency for a manager's tactical instructions to bed in, and while some coaches can keep it simple and play five formations in their first five matches, that's not necessarily flexibility so much as shallowness.

Fundamentally I don't think the problem is being wedded to one tactic, it's that with our injuries at the back, poor recruitment up front, and multiple players out of form in the midfield, we're not really equipped for anything SDG or Reedijk have been trying to achieve. Jim Goodwin couldn't outthink Ryan69 ffs, he's not sussed anything, he just had a team in good rhythm vs one distinctly not
To be fair to Jim Badloss nobody could out think the enigma that is Ryan69.
I'd be worried if I could.
 
This is a massive window coming up in January, and the manager needs to be strong. He’s not the one responsible for the recruitment decisions - there’s a team in place that are all culpable.

If the window is another failure then yes by all means make those accountable for failure. FFS don’t change the manager just to hide the heat from those culpable.
Or those above……………………
 
Hi everyone,
a couple of things, 1/ I assume Garvan Stewart has lost the Black Knight recruitment resources after the partnership break up which could be a big loss.
2/ we got spanked 5-1 by Chelsea a few games ago, since then 9 wins in a row, so never lose the hope that the team can turn it round, starting v Dundee.

I think part of the issue was they were ignoring the black knight resources
 
The same recruitment team are going to try and right their wrongs from the summer window in January, same as they did last summer. There’s zero accountability for the business they do, unless of course we end up relegated.

It’s early days but I’m convinced Reedijk is up to the job at all, a good talker full of buzzwords (we know the Gordon’s love that) but like many young / inexperienced coaches he seems welded to a single tactical approach and can’t change. Jim Goodwin had that sussed, an even worse sign is John McGlynn had that sussed in Reedijk’s second game.

All seems a bit doom and gloom, but I think the Hearts & Aberdeen games were outliers, and the rest of the performances - the inability to defend as a unit, that teams can easily cut us open with one pass, the inability to press as a collective, no patterns of play to give the player on the ball a forward option, not enough players in the box when we do get forward - are a reflection of where we are. The change of manager has had no impact.

I think we would have won at Hampden and Aberdeen if we hadn’t changed managers. Fairly sure we would have won at home by now too. I accept that’s probably churlish, but Tuesday is now must win along with Saturday.