Full Time: Hibs 0 v 4 Dundee United

Our defense got carved open far too easily. Salinger was not good enough today. I thought we played ok at times, some good, clever passing occasionally but not creating good scoring chances. Utd were good but we need to defend better than that.
 
Our defense got carved open far too easily. Salinger was not good enough today. I thought we played ok at times, some good, clever passing occasionally but not creating good scoring chances. Utd were good but we need to defend better than that.
Agree. Sallinger could be worth dropping
 
It’s widely known Dundee United’s midfield three have been excellent this season at controlling games and being the platform they build their attacking and defending from.

Reedijk did absolutely nothing in the way the team were set up to combat that. That is bad enough but to do nothing at half time to address it is absolutely dreadful football management. Chaiwa and Mulligan should have been nowhere near that second half.

Some of the players were a simply awful today and need to take a long hard look at themselves, and we all know the squad assembled in the summer is miles off it in terms of quality in key areas, but the manager has had plenty time to have the team to be well organised out of possession.

He needs to make some big calls in terms of his tactics and team selections very quickly. Dundee are just as capable of doing the same to us on Tuesday as their neighbours have today. No sure Reedijk can afford many more pumpings like that… unfortunately the semi final performance looks and outlier, while Aberdeen had chucked it under Robinson.

Relegation is a real possibility - Aberdeen have made a change and their new guy has won as many league games as ours, and he’s only had one game. Killie are likely to make a change, if that’s positive we could be in real trouble.
 
Sallinger wasnae the problem today, and was probably our man of the match

Goodwin done a number on Marink, I agree with some of Zab above on how he should have responded - that's a worry as we should have galvanized and got to half time 1 down and then changed things. Our manager seemed particularly green today.
 
It’s widely known Dundee United’s midfield three have been excellent this season at controlling games and being the platform they build their attacking and defending from.

Reedijk did absolutely nothing in the way the team were set up to combat that. That is bad enough but to do nothing at half time to address it is absolutely dreadful football management. Chaiwa and Mulligan should have been nowhere near that second half.

Some of the players were a simply awful today and need to take a long hard look at themselves, and we all know the squad assembled in the summer is miles off it in terms of quality in key areas, but the manager has had plenty time to have the team to be well organised out of possession.

He needs to make some big calls in terms of his tactics and team selections very quickly. Dundee are just as capable of doing the same to us on Tuesday as their neighbours have today. No sure Reedijk can afford many more pumpings like that… unfortunately the semi final performance looks and outlier, while Aberdeen had chucked it under Robinson.

Relegation is a real possibility - Aberdeen have made a change and their new guy has won as many league games as ours, and he’s only had one game. Killie are likely to make a change, if that’s positive we could be in real trouble.
Also, why did we hardly give the ball to Boyle? He's been brilliant recently but we just did not give him the ball.
 
I have a theory, which more often than not works out. Football managers seldom recover from a dreadful scudding. Whichever way you want to dress it up, getting beat 4 nowt at home is a dreadful scudding. I hope in this case my theory is wrong, but I don't see any evidence to suggest so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zab
Sallinger wasnae the problem today, and was probably our man of the match

Goodwin done a number on Marink, I agree with some of Zab above on how he should have responded - that's a worry as we should have galvanized and got to half time 1 down and then changed things. Our manager seemed particularly green today.
Surprised with that P&G, thought the keeper looked very wobbly today. MoM? Should never be beat near post for the second shirley
 
I have a theory, which more often than not works out. Football managers seldom recover from a dreadful scudding. Whichever way you want to dress it up, getting beat 4 nowt at home is a dreadful scudding. I hope in this case my theory is wrong, but I don't see any evidence to suggest so.
Hibs & Hertz are both fkd then 💣
 
I hope during the next international break we have the players in at training 7 days a week. Whatever the fuck they did during the time off has regressed us ten fold.
 
Sallinger wasnae the problem today, and was probably our man of the match

Goodwin done a number on Marink, I agree with some of Zab above on how he should have responded - that's a worry as we should have galvanized and got to half time 1 down and then changed things. Our manager seemed particularly green today.
Unfortunately there was no MOM today. Can't understand why he never pushed the penalty outwards. Also second goal his position is all wrong.
Kerr for me is the weakest link.
 
That's what you call a reality check.

The last two results, great though they were, were an aberration in an otherwise woeful season so far.
Today Hibs were completely outfought and outplayed from start to finish by a far superior team who should have won by more than the four goals they did.
Our home form in 2026 as been Butcher-like...and if we don't get our arse into gear very soon we are going to suffer the same fate as we did back then in 2014.

A defence that is error prone and indecisive, a soft as shite midfield that is not competitive and doesn't create anything, and forwards who never get into the box, make the wrong decisions constantly, and pass up what precious few chances that are created for them.

Todays game showed everyone the reality of where Hibs actually are in November 2026, and it is not a pretty sight.
Reedijk to his credit has worked hard to try to turn things round in short period of time, but it's at Easter Road where the vast majority of Hibs fans watch their games, and our home form has been catastrophic this year, both under Gray and now Reedijk.

The Dundee game on Tuesday night becomes huge now.
They are just as capable as United are of beating Hibs at Easter Road, so we have to change things big time.

One can only guess where Hibs go from here.
What a fucking shambles this club has become.
 
Are we allowed to have ago at Newall again? That's a joke btw. They were all a fucking disgrace and there is nothing to take away from that other than it was utter shite.
 
Unfortunately there was no MOM today. Can't understand why he never pushed the penalty outwards. Also second goal his position is all wrong.
Kerr for me is the weakest link.
Unless it's a weakly struck penalty a goalkeeper has no say in how they parry the ball. All they are trying to do is a) go the right way and B) block it.

Sallinger may have been poor today but he was not at fault in any way with the penalty.
 
Anyone who knows me will know I usually come up with something positive after a poor result. When my stream went down for the second time today I just switched it off. That was the only positive for me today. Team seemed to shrink back into their shells today - indecisive, slow to react, careless, frightened. Very disappointing - good thing the LC Final tickets were on sale before today.
 
Unless it's a weakly struck penalty a goalkeeper has no say in how they parry the ball. All they are trying to do is a) go the right way and B) block it.

Sallinger may have been poor today but he was not at fault in any way with the penalty.
Agree with that
 
Wasnt fooled by the games against them and the sheep, welcome as the wins were.

Gray/Mackay left Marink with a shit defence. Gray's rigid sticking to 3 at the back as a system left us with not one solid fullback at the club just a pick n mix of wingbacks who can barely tackle a pie supper. I mean anyone seriously think Williams and Iredale can play fullback? Mayor, Obita and Passlack arent fullbacks either.
And dont get me started on the centre of defence ie Kerr. That's Gray's legacy.

Even so I thought Chaiwa, Mulligan and Newell didnt turn up today. Iqbal, Cameron and Tait bossed us in the centre of the park.

Up front it didnt gel but thats not why we shipped 4 goals and we'll have better days up front.

You build from the back. Every decent manager knows that. Across the back 4 we're soft as shit. we dont cut out crosses, and players just drift into our penalty box and head home goals unchallenged.

Got no idea how we can change this before Jan. Gray and Mackay are to blame.

And please dont start talking shit about Josh Campbell. He isnt the answer either. 2 full backs and a centre back are needed.
 
Wasnt fooled by the games against them and the sheep, welcome as the wins were.

Gray/Mackay left Marink with a shit defence. Gray's rigid sticking to 3 at the back as a system left us with not one solid fullback at the club just a pick n mix of wingbacks who can barely tackle a pie supper. I mean anyone seriously think Williams and Iredale can play fullback? Mayor, Obita and Passlack arent fullbacks either.
And dont get me started on the centre of defence ie Kerr. That's Gray's legacy.

Even so I thought Chaiwa, Mulligan and Newell didnt turn up today. Iqbal, Cameron and Tait bossed us in the centre of the park.

Up front it didnt gel but thats not why we shipped 4 goals and we'll have better days up front.

You build from the back. Every decent manager knows that. Across the back 4 we're soft as shit. we dont cut out crosses, and players just drift into our penalty box and head home goals unchallenged.

Got no idea how we can change this before Jan. Gray and Mackay are to blame.

And please dont start talking shit about Josh Campbell. He isnt the answer either. 2 full backs and a centre back are needed.
I agree with you
 
Wasnt fooled by the games against them and the sheep, welcome as the wins were.

Gray/Mackay left Marink with a shit defence. Gray's rigid sticking to 3 at the back as a system left us with not one solid fullback at the club just a pick n mix of wingbacks who can barely tackle a pie supper. I mean anyone seriously think Williams and Iredale can play fullback? Mayor, Obita and Passlack arent fullbacks either.
And dont get me started on the centre of defence ie Kerr. That's Gray's legacy.

Even so I thought Chaiwa, Mulligan and Newell didnt turn up today. Iqbal, Cameron and Tait bossed us in the centre of the park.

Up front it didnt gel but thats not why we shipped 4 goals and we'll have better days up front.

You build from the back. Every decent manager knows that. Across the back 4 we're soft as shit. we dont cut out crosses, and players just drift into our penalty box and head home goals unchallenged.

Got no idea how we can change this before Jan. Gray and Mackay are to blame.

And please dont start talking shit about Josh Campbell. He isnt the answer either. 2 full backs and a centre back are needed.
Could do with a striker aswell, the ones we've got are toothless, miss far to many chances.
 
I left at 0-4 I knew we wouldn't score 1.
What a fuckin shambles that was today.
It was really poor, albeit against a really good Dundee Utd team. These games ‘happen’…just ask the Dundee supporters! Tuesday will be ‘interesting’; 2 teams coming off bad results with something to ‘prove’. I was not getting carried away with our last couple of results and I’m not thinking the worst after today.