Edinburgh

Bane2013

New radge
Joined
Mar 7, 2013
Just finished working my way through the rebus novels (I know, I was a late starter) and the way rankin describes and portrays the city got me thinking. Edinburgh is a fantastic city! It has folds and different facets that mark it different to Glasgow. Having been Glasgow recently, I found it a sterile and cold place with no real character or sense of history. Edinburgh is a city where you can feel the history surround you when you walk around it and it has a uniqueness about it, a character I don't think any other city in the uk can match with the possible exception of London.

Maybe I'm waxing lyrical but Edinburgh..... It's fantastic!
 
I used to have a wee walk round Calton Hill at lunch time, I work pretty close by.

Quite often I'd get chatting with tourists from all over the world.

Fantastic views of the whole city and a wee story about Hibs as we looked over to Easter Road, or the spot where the Proclaimers stood and looked over Sunshine on Leith.

On the other side, the Old Town and the Royal Mile was when I pointed out to Americans that we had pubs older than their country :-D

Jack will soon be available for city tours with a difference ;-)
 
I have been fortunate enough over the years to visit quite a number of cities in the world, some are fantastic, some are not. Edinburgh for me easily stands comparison with the best of them. I think when you are brought up in a a city you kind of take it for granted, but I really do think Edinburgh is unique. A stunning city...
 
Last edited:
Edinburgh is fantastic and the only place in Scotland that I'd be interested in living in. It compares well with best of them although for me the romes, parises, london s of the world are in another league.

Pity the council seem hell bent on messing the place up!
 
I used to have a wee walk round Calton Hill at lunch time, I work pretty close by.

Quite often I'd get chatting with tourists from all over the world.

Fantastic views of the whole city and a wee story about Hibs as we looked over to Easter Road, or the spot where the Proclaimers stood and looked over Sunshine on Leith.

On the other side, the Old Town and the Royal Mile was when I pointed out to Americans that we had pubs older than their country :-D

Jack will soon be available for city tours with a difference ;-)
a regular calton hill 'stroller'? I see :coffee:
 
Edinburgh is fantastic and the only place in Scotland that I'd be interested in living in. It compares well with best of them although for me the romes, parises, london s of the world are in another league.

Pity the council seem hell bent on messing the place up!

Yeah, i feel the council do and always have done, have a village mentality.
They have held Edinburgh back immensely.
Takes years for any project to get going, there seems to be an attitude that Edinburgh is beautiful we don't need to do anything.....
 
Nice place to take pictures of, and I doubt I'll live anywhere else in Scotland until I retire, but feck me it's a tough place to live/work.Terrible roads,a council hell bent on turning certain parts of it into shanty towns,decaying schools and hospitals that take decades to replace and we have to share it with the savilles.As far as the four main Scottish cities goes, it's just about 1st, but in comparison to places of the same size like Copenhagen,Reykjavik or Stockholm it lacks, from what I've witnessed.
 
Just finished working my way through the rebus novels (I know, I was a late starter) and the way rankin describes and portrays the city got me thinking. Edinburgh is a fantastic city! It has folds and different facets that mark it different to Glasgow. Having been Glasgow recently, I found it a sterile and cold place with no real character or sense of history. Edinburgh is a city where you can feel the history surround you when you walk around it and it has a uniqueness about it, a character I don't think any other city in the uk can match with the possible exception of London.

Maybe I'm waxing lyrical but Edinburgh..... It's fantastic!

Reasonable fishing attempt.I think Glasgow is quality.Certain social issues, nothing much different to Edinburgh, just on a larger scale.
 
Just finished working my way through the rebus novels (I know, I was a late starter) and the way rankin describes and portrays the city got me thinking. Edinburgh is a fantastic city! It has folds and different facets that mark it different to Glasgow. Having been Glasgow recently, I found it a sterile and cold place with no real character or sense of history. Edinburgh is a city where you can feel the history surround you when you walk around it and it has a uniqueness about it, a character I don't think any other city in the uk can match with the possible exception of London.

Maybe I'm waxing lyrical but Edinburgh..... It's fantastic!


That strikes me as unfair. For all its faults, and all places have faults not least Edinburgh, Glasgow is a pretty vibrant city that rewards the visitor with a varied and rich culture. Most of those visitors agree that the city's people have a very warm and welcoming personality.

Of course, all cities to some degree are mythologised both by the people who live there and the people who don't. And one person's personal experience of a place can be completely different from everyone else and completely at odds with the stereotyped version of a city's reputation. But if that is really how you found Glasgow I would suggest you give it another go. You might be surprised.

As for Edinburgh? Well, God knows it ain't perfect and the Cooncil seem to be doing their utmost to ruin the place, but I still wouldn't up sticks for anywhere else. It takes the breath away, and when I come up into Princes Street from Waverly Station having been away for any length of time and get a peek at the place again I can forgive any of its faults and even see that one day, once the Cooncil have stopped fucking about with it, it can come alive again.
 
Honestly no fishing. I just found Glasgow to be very mundane. No history or atmosphere about it but that's only my opinion, fair do's if you disagree but nae fishing here
 
I have mixed feeling about Edinburgh these days. There is a lot going for it but the tram works have been a real downer the past couple of years. The Royal Mile and Princess Street have way too many tartan tat shops. Rose Street looks pretty run down and plagued with hen/stag parties. But over all it's still a great city.
 
I have mixed feeling about Edinburgh these days. There is a lot going for it but the tram works have been a real downer the past couple of years. The Royal Mile and Princess Street have way too many tartan tat shops. Rose Street looks pretty run down and plagued with hen/stag parties. But over all it's still a great city.

Past couple years? Nearly a decade now.
 
It's by far my favourite place in the UK. Stirling is the only place scenically I know that gives it a run for it's money, though some English villages are also gorgeous. However, you can never be bored in Reekie.

The very best view of the city is on the North Bridge, especially on a crisp winters day when there is a dusting of snaw on Arthurs seat.

You really need to live away from Stirling and Edinburgh for a while to really take in how special they are.

The rest of urban Scotland is terrible though, except maybe St Andrews.
 
where's your nearest peatbank? teuchter smilie

I suppose its no bad for a weekend

:pf:
 
I just found Glasgow to be very mundane. No history or atmosphere about it

Apart from a major industrial heritage where at one time over half of all UK shipping and 1 in 4 of all the train locomotives in the world were Glasgow built and a merchant city built upon a massive tobacco and cotton trade.

Crookston Castle from 1400, Haggs Castle from the 1500's, Glasgow Cathedral from the 12th C, the only medieval cathedral to survive the reformation intact, a three storey house, the Provand's Lordship, still sitting there on the High St built in 1471, Glasgow Uni the 4th oldest university in the English speaking world, battles fought within the current city boundaries involving William Wallace and Mary Queen Of Scots, Glasgow Green where Bonnie Prince Charlie and his jacobite army stayed for a week.

The Harry Hopkins Suite in the Millenium Hotel, George Square, the room where Churchill burst into tears when told the USA would join the war effort with the Lend-Lease law, George Square also the scene of Black Friday 1919 when British Army tanks were deployed on the streets of Glasgow to quell a revolution, a city which was also a central location in the 1820 Radical War, the circular office that overlooks Glasgow Central Station where a young John F Kennedy met the US survivors of the SS Athenia sinking, the Glasgow Central Hotel where the first ever long distance TV images were transmitted to by Logie Baird and of course Glasgow's the home to three different football grounds where Hibs won major trophies, Cathkin Park, Celtic Park and Hampden Park.

That's all off the top of my head - every city has plenty of history if you look.

Edinburgh however is a stunning looking city and very atmospheric.
 
Apart from a major industrial heritage where at one time over half of all UK shipping and 1 in 4 of all the train locomotives in the world were Glasgow built and a merchant city built upon a massive tobacco and cotton trade.

Crookston Castle from 1400, Haggs Castle from the 1500's, Glasgow Cathedral from the 12th C, the only medieval cathedral to survive the reformation intact, a three storey house, the Provand's Lordship, still sitting there on the High St built in 1471, Glasgow Uni the 4th oldest university in the English speaking world, battles fought within the current city boundaries involving William Wallace and Mary Queen Of Scots, Glasgow Green where Bonnie Prince Charlie and his jacobite army stayed for a week.

The Harry Hopkins Suite in the Millenium Hotel, George Square, the room where Churchill burst into tears when told the USA would join the war effort with the Lend-Lease law, George Square also the scene of Black Friday 1919 when British Army tanks were deployed on the streets of Glasgow to quell a revolution, a city which was also a central location in the 1820 Radical War, the circular office that overlooks Glasgow Central Station where a young John F Kennedy met the US survivors of the SS Athenia sinking, the Glasgow Central Hotel where the first ever long distance TV images were transmitted to by Logie Baird and of course Glasgow's the home to three different football grounds where Hibs won major trophies, Cathkin Park, Celtic Park and Hampden Park.

That's all off the top of my head - every city has plenty of history if you look.

Edinburgh however is a stunning looking city and very atmospheric.

Was reading the other day Glasgow was building so many ships at one point there was a ship builder ( of some repute) building in Polmadie...about a mile from the Clyde...one of their ships is quite famous, it's regarded as the oldest working ship in Africa, The Chauncy Maples, which is used as a hospital ship on Lake Malawi. Glasgows industrial history is unrivalled in The UK and brilliant, imo.
 
I've to agree with this. I'm not Scottish (or even from the UK) but have traveled Scotland fairly extensively and Edinburgh is by far my favourite city in the all of UK. London might have more stuff to do generally but it doesn't have the same feeling Edinburgh does - at this point I almost feel like visiting home every time I go there, even though I've never actually lived there.