Charlie Richmond

[Mr Magoo]

What a total wazik

[Jamie]

Defo a spade like

[DarrenSQH]

Least he didnt send zemmama off when he should have for that stupid handball.

[©stretch]

Originally Posted by Mr Magoo

What a total wazik

Fcukin mince from start to finish.

Hibs player fouls some hun bastard=Booked
Hun bastard fouls Hibs player/falls like he's been shot/throws ball away= wee talking to.

Romanob is as mad as a box of frogs, but he maybe has a point regarding ref's.

[Smurf]

The Jones booking was pathetic as he won the ball. Is a tackle now no longer a legitimate part of football?

However, he could have sent off Zemmama..

[Mr Magoo]

the man is a poor excuse for a ref, he never let the game flow

[emerald green]

Originally Posted by ©stretch

Fcukin mince from start to finish.

Hibs player fouls some hun bastard=Booked
Hun bastard fouls Hibs player/falls like he's been shot/throws ball away= wee talking to.

Romanob is as mad as a box of frogs, but he maybe has a point regarding ref's.

Correct.

Think hes reffed us bout 15 times and we've yet to register a win.

[Johnny Kash]

Originally Posted by Smurf

The Jones booking was pathetic as he won the ball. Is a tackle now no longer a legitimate part of football?

However, he could have sent off Zemmama..

That was an absolute raker of a tackle by the big man

one of the few highlights of a dissappointing game

[gackohibs]

did my head in today.
chris burke should a get a olympic diving gold medal.

despite the very poor referee, si brown cost us the 3 points.
i think he shares a bed with zibi!!

[HibeeJibee]

Boyd had an outrageous dive in the first half which but didn't even get a talking to.

I also felt really disappointed that Lewis Stevenson was booked, OK it was a foul but it was a pretty minor one and only his second minor one of the day. It was nothing.

But Zemmama was stupid, he could have easily been sent-off, which we can't afford.

[GloryGlory]

Fecking Charlie Adam 2 clear dives right infront of the ref which the ref says are dives and doesnt give a foul. How the fuck is that not 2 bookings alone never mind the rest of the fouls.

How many fouls did it take for Ferguson to get booked? Richmond was their best player, a fecking disgrace.

[GlesgaeHibby]

Originally Posted by HibeeJibee

Boyd had an outrageous dive in the first half which but didn't even get a talking to.

I also felt really disappointed that Lewis Stevenson was booked, OK it was a foul but it was a pretty minor one and only his second minor one of the day. It was nothing.

But Zemmama was stupid, he could have easily been sent-off, which we can't afford.

Ref was appalling. Although disagree with your views on Stevenson. He had a great game, but that was a silly tackle. They had 13 players tho in Richmond and Simon Brown.

[Lix]

Ok, I'll no doubt get shot down in flames, but I actually thought Richmond was ok.

Not great - the usual bias when it comes to deciding who to book (I thought Zemmama was very unlucky with his booking as it was completely accidental when he caught Burke for instance) but otherwise I've seen him ref far worse. He was sensible in not sending off Zemmama for the hand ball where he should've gone given his booking already... although i guess two wrongs don't make a right ...

Ok, that's maybe not saying much, but I don't think you can blame the ref for today.

Simon Brown, without a doubt, but not the ref ....

[HibeeJibee]

Agree with you there Lix, many of our fans are starting to sound like Yams (God forbid). Richmond wasn't against us, OK he probably gave more cards to us and less to them than would be fair, but otherwise he had an OK game and best you can expect.

I say that because the standard of referees in Scotland has gone through the floor, what would be give for a Dallas, Young, McDonald, even (possibly) a Rowbotham?

The days of European finals, and World Cup matches, being refereed by Scots is long gone.

[cavalier]

Originally Posted by HibeeJibee

Agree with you there Lix, many of our fans are starting to sound like Yams (God forbid). Richmond wasn't against us, OK he probably gave more cards to us and less to them than would be fair, but otherwise he had an OK game and best you can expect.

I say that because the standard of referees in Scotland has gone through the floor, what would be give for a Dallas, Young, McDonald, even (possibly) a Rowbotham?

The days of European finals, and World Cup matches, being refereed by Scots is long gone.

Too far, way too far!!

[Forzahibs]

Jones booking was a very good tackle , can't understand why the linesman didn't get involved though

[KABULHIBBY]

Originally Posted by Lix

Ok, I'll no doubt get shot down in flames, but I actually thought Richmond was ok.

Not great - the usual bias when it comes to deciding who to book (I thought Zemmama was very unlucky with his booking as it was completely accidental when he caught Burke for instance) but otherwise I've seen him ref far worse. He was sensible in not sending off Zemmama for the hand ball where he should've gone given his booking already... although i guess two wrongs don't make a right ...

Ok, that's maybe not saying much, but I don't think you can blame the ref for today.

Simon Brown, without a doubt, but not the ref ....

Tend to agree with your observations on the ref Lix, I think that he was at the wrong side for the Jones tackle and his assistant should have flagged that it was a good tackle with a throw in to the bigots.

Also felt that he tried to keep the game flowing as much as possible whilst keeping the cards to a minimum, we can't complain about Boyd not getting booked when Zoomer should have seen . He applied a bit of common sense in the majority of his decisions but wasn't helped by the palyers

[davhfc]

I didnt think the ref was good today, he took far too long to book boyd and ferguson, I thought when brown went through into the box that mcgregor caught him. We werent great and neither was he.

[KeithTheHibee]

Was verrrrrrrrrry dubious with some of (if not all) of the free kicks he gave to Rangers, one of which resulted in the first goal. Booked Jones for a perfectly good challenge, and waited until Boyd had 4 tackles before booking him. Whenever a tackle went in, he pulled it back. Referee aside, did anyone notice when the wee ned was pulling Jones' shirt, and Jones just pushed him out the way? About time someone did!

[HutchieHibee]

Originally Posted by gackohibs

chris burke should a get a olympic diving gold medal.

actually his diving was so pathetically bad he would get nowhere


unless all the judges where sash wearing goat shaggers

[HutchieHibee]

[quote=Lix;595187 He was sensible in not sending off Zemmama for the hand ball where he should've gone given his booking already... although i guess two wrongs don't make a right ... [/QUOTE]

from where I was sitting Richmond bottled it... he saw the offence, started to go for the card, then must have realised what was up as he hesitated and did nothing more


the big problem I have with Richmond's refereeing today is his acceptance of some outrageous dissent from Rangers players...

while getting uptight and angry when any Hibs player moaned about a discision

[18-Ally-75]

Originally Posted by Almighty Hibee

Referee aside, did anyone notice when the wee ned was pulling Jones' shirt, and Jones just pushed him out the way? About time someone did!

I did . That was one of a few higlights in the 2nd half. The wee ned gettin knocked over after Benji's shot was deflected i found even better And wen Boozy chased Katie back and left him on his backside. About the ref i thought he had a shocker. Hibs should of had 2 penalty's today. The scott brown 1 and when Jones was being wrestled by Ehiogh as he went for a header. Also when he evntually gave hibs a freekick in a dangerous position if he'd just let the game go Brown had an open goal to shoot at from the edge of the area. Shocking refereeing in my mind

[Forzahibs]

The SB one was nothing like a pen but there was a blatant shove on Murphy (think it was him) late in the game