A Collins perpective on Zibi ???

[Greenman]

Don't hold your breath waiting on Collins dumping Zibi


Collins said: "At set pieces we looked a bit shaky. The golden rule of defending is you never wait for the ball, you go and attack. But we waited.

"It wasn't just the goalkeeper's fault, there were guys in front of him. We don't want to blame individuals

Its going to be a long season

[JamieHibby]

Originally Posted by Greenman

Don't hold your breath waiting on Collins dumping Zibi


Collins said: "At set pieces we looked a bit shaky. The golden rule of defending is you never wait for the ball, you go and attack. But we waited.

"It wasn't just the goalkeeper's fault, there were guys in front of him. We don't want to blame individuals

Its going to be a long season

Sure will be if that clown isn't dumped

Whether he was entirely to blame today or not isn't really the main issue any more, not as far as I am concerned but he has cost us enough in the past. It seems pretty obvious that the whole team and and the defence in particular has lost all confidence in him. They may be making mistakes and trying things they shouldn't but that clearly seems to me to be because thay don't trust him to be doing what he should be doing. He is the underlying cause of the nervousness and mistakes.

He comes off his line when he shouldn't and ends up fapping at it, he doesn't when he should, nobody knows what the fuck he is going to do.
He can't kick properly, usually goes out the park
His distribution and decision making are dire, he doesn't release it when we have a chance to break, he does throw it out to players when they have some-one right up their erse.

He is crap and he has to go

[Thomson_19]

Surely to christ not.

When it gets to the stage where the home fans boo you at first then sarcastically applaud/cheer when he picks the ball up it's a clear sign that we have had enough.

Might have just missed the thread on it but I have also noticed no one has signalled there disgust at a Hibs player getting booed by their own fans which, considering folk defended Amadou and Caldwell when they were the victims, say's it all for me.

Zibi is more than a liability, he's just shite, why can't they just admit it and get him to fuck?

[Dub]

Originally Posted by Airghialla Gaiscíoch

Sure will be if that clown isn't dumped

Whether he was entirely to blame today or not isn't really the main issue any more, not as far as I am concerned but he has cost us enough in the past. It seems pretty obvious that the whole team and and the defence in particular has lost all confidence in him. They may be making mistakes and trying things they shouldn't but that clearly seems to me to be because thay don't trust him to be doing what he should be doing.

1. He is the underlying cause of the nervousness and mistakes.

2.He comes off his line when he shouldn't and ends up fapping at it, he doesn't when he should, nobody knows what the fuck he is going to do.

3.He can't kick properly, usually goes out the park

4.His distribution and decision making are dire, he doesn't release it when we have a chance to break, he does throw it out to players when they have some-one right up their erse.

He is crap and he has to go

Apart from the points you made, he's alright though( WTF my smilie didnt work - oh well). I posted on another thread that the whole defence was to blame for the second goal, the ball could easily have been lumped up the park when it wasnt but Zibbi certainly had a hand in the goal - no pun intended I assure you.

[hibbill2002]

Originally Posted by Airghialla Gaiscíoch

Sure will be if that clown isn't dumped

Whether he was entirely to blame today or not isn't really the main issue any more, not as far as I am concerned but he has cost us enough in the past. It seems pretty obvious that the whole team and and the defence in particular has lost all confidence in him. They may be making mistakes and trying things they shouldn't but that clearly seems to me to be because thay don't trust him to be doing what he should be doing. He is the underlying cause of the nervousness and mistakes.

He comes off his line when he shouldn't and ends up fapping at it, he doesn't when he should, nobody knows what the fuck he is going to do.
He can't kick properly, usually goes out the park
His distribution and decision making are dire, he doesn't release it when we have a chance to break, he does throw it out to players when they have some-one right up their erse.

He is crap and he has to go

i think thats out of order ...if your going to say something, just say it, dont be beating about the bush

seriously though, zibi just isnae good enough

[bigmanandy]

It is going to be a long season as with Zibby in goals we are going to drop points home and away and he is going to make silly mistakes.

Has Collins actually been watching Zibby over the past few months or has he just come in and thought hmm he must be good as Mogga has made him the first choice goalie, well all ive got to say is, Collins take a look at some of the blunders hes made in the past and get him out of the team!

[blue toon hibby]

Originally Posted by bigmanandy

It is going to be a long season as with Zibby in goals we are going to drop points home and away and he is going to make silly mistakes.

Has Collins actually been watching Zibby over the past few months or has he just come in and thought hmm he must be good as Mogga has made him the first choice goalie, well all ive got to say is, Collins take a look at some of the blunders hes made in the past and get him out of the team!

And all I can say is Mandy FFS give the guy time - he's only been in the job 5 minutes!

[bigmanandy]

Originally Posted by blue toon hibby

And all I can say is Mandy FFS give the guy time - he's only been in the job 5 minutes!

I'll give him the time orite, but i does get to me how not many former players have suceeded as a manager of the same club and the last one to have any success was Turbull, so all we can do is wait and see.

[Dub]

Originally Posted by bigmanandy

I'll give him the time orite, but i does get to me how not many former players have suceeded as a manager of the same club and the last one to have any success was Turbull, so all we can do is wait and see.

Sounds like you're gearing yourself up to blame Collins for eveything Mandy. Hope I'm wrong there.

[bigmanandy]

Originally Posted by Dub

Sounds like you're gearing yourself up to blame Collins for eveything Mandy. Hope I'm wrong there.

Nah i'm not, i'm sure Collins can pool it off, he just needs to time...and i do understand it is his first job so i will defo give him the time.

[GloryGlory]

If you look at every teams keepers in the league I'd take any one of them. Probably even their reserve goalies. We are the only team with a shite goalie. Theres Mark Brown, Graeme Smith, Alan McGregor maybe others who are all young goalies who have been given their chance and are doing fine. McNeil has to be put in.

[HibeePaddy]

There is an element of the Hibs support who didnt want Collins as manager and are now desperate for him to fail. These will be the same people that booed the team off at the end yesterday. Give the man time ffs. I suggest these fans take a long hard look at themselves and if they aint going to support the team and new manager (the atmosphere and support for the team yesterday was awful) they dont bother coming at all.

Now then now thats off my chest...a derby win on wednesday anyone?

[blue toon hibby]

Originally Posted by bigmanandy

I'll give him the time orite, but i does get to me how not many former players have suceeded as a manager of the same club and the last one to have any success was Turbull, so all we can do is wait and see.

So just take your own advice then - wait and see. Collins is not blind or stupid. He'll make what changes he sees fit, hopefully without the fans getting on his back after only one game in charge.

[Galloway Hibby]

Zibi is making the rest of the defence jittery big rob @ martis
were fine until the yambos games i would go for Rab Douglas
I would give big Rob the captains arm band Thomo losing out since he took it

[Greenman]

Originally Posted by Galloway Hibby

Zibi is making the rest of the defence jittery big rob @ martis
were fine until the yambos games i would go for Rab Douglas
I would give big Rob the captains arm band Thomo losing out since he took it

Rab Douglas is worse than Zibi

[Davy]

Has Brown left? I noticed McNeil was on bench (pity he wasnt used as a sub)

[Pilrig]

Originally Posted by HibeePaddy

There is an element of the Hibs support who didnt want Collins as manager and are now desperate for him to fail. These will be the same people that booed the team off at the end yesterday. Give the man time ffs. I suggest these fans take a long hard look at themselves and if they aint going to support the team and new manager (the atmosphere and support for the team yesterday was awful) they dont bother coming at all.

I don't believe there's Hibs supporters wanting Collins to fail, even though he wasn't their fisrt choice as boss. Don't believe that for a second. My preferred choice was Mixu, but I hope to God Collins turns out to be a success at ER, I even hoped that Blobby would turn oot to be a success...in that case my reservations proved correct.
BUT for Christ's sake we can't have Zibi Blunderman berween the sticks on Wednesday - doesn't bear thinking about. An ambitious football manager has to be ruthless when it comes to picking the team......I'm sure JC realises that.

[Pilrig]

Originally Posted by Greenman

Rab Douglas is worse than Zibi

Both are butter-fingered huddies when it comes to big games.

[Dr Shrink]

I see there are reports on the Hibslist that Zibi has signed a 3 year deal, set up by Mowbray before he left.








I haven't received the follow up e-mail yet.

The one with the punch line.

It IS a joke isn't it?

[Greenmachine]

Originally Posted by Dr Shrink

I see there are reports on the Hibslist that Zibi has signed a 3 year deal, set up by Mowbray before he left.








I haven't received the follow up e-mail yet.

The one with the punch line.

It IS a joke isn't it?

One of the reporters on Radio Scotland mentioned this today. I don't think he has signed it yet, and I doubt he will if the new manager has anything to do with it.