Whitty for midfield

[hibeejo]

Whittakers performance on sunday was one of the only bright points for us, looked at ease on the ball, confident and lead by example, would seriously think about perm midfield for him.

[Young_hibee]

a really wasnt to impressed by him outstanding last season. Really dont think this has been his season.

[hibbypotter]

if he does get a shot in midfield some one better teach him how to shoot

[GloryGlory]

Originally Posted by hibeejo

Whittakers performance on sunday was one of the only bright points for us, looked at ease on the ball, confident and lead by example, would seriously think about perm midfield for him.

Defensivly was he any better than he is at right back
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Not imo.

[Cal_Hibby_4_Life]

at least mogga finally put him in midfield, and got him out of defence

[Young_hibee]

Originally Posted by Em

But he's no good there either
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

lets no judge him on one game then wel keep should keep him their for another wee while and see how he progresses

[hibskeepdafaith]

Whitty needs to be in midfeild he is one of the strongest players we have got and i think he just dosnt show his full potencial in right back. we need him in the box for corners as well.

wee gemz age 14 (i know wat im on about)

[No.7 Morri]

for me hes got to bak in a right bak, been 1 of the most consistent performers ther and lets face it we can play other good players in midfield when they come bak from injuries etc but cant see any1 else playing at right back!

[stevieboi]

its quite amusing in a sad kind of way really. Up till sunday most people on here , myself included have been striving Mogga gets that useless guy out the defence and into midfield, and when we finally do it and on paper it looks a fairly strong back four you have to say, we still go and conceade four goals. Really dont no what Whittys best position is now to be honest was not that impressed with his contibution in his midfield role. Would like to see him played their more often though as he makes our right flank very liable.

[CadgeMac]

Originally Posted by Em

Are you on drugs???

Whittaker was a disgrace and has been all season

nah cant agree with that

[Jack_hibernian]

he had about 4 shots that blazed over the bar. Caldwell can just piss off now

[CadgeMac]

Originally Posted by Jack_hibernian

he had about 4 shots that blazed over the bar. Caldwell can just piss off now

least he wasn't scared to take a shot, he drove forward and showed commitment

[Hibby_chick9]

was that were he was ment to be playing, he was pish , was never where he was ment to be kept gettin dragged into the middle leaving the whole side free were that jose guy jus ran down , he got one shot out of the 5 or sumit he skyed over the bar!! he wasnt the greatest like

[CadgeMac]

Originally Posted by Em

To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.


How no
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.


He has been inconsistent all season which everybody has blamed on him being in defence then when he's played in midfield he is even worse
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

at the start of the season he was playing well, i agree he has been on a poor run but on sunday compared to the rest of the team he was one of the better players. he drove at hearts and wasn't scared to have a shot even if they weren't that great atleast he had a shot. as ive said before and i will say again i feel whittaker is been used as a scapegoat this season as everyone seems to blame him when they should be looking at the whole team.

[alnewhaven]

Maybe the experimenting with players in different positions, should have happened before Sunday? Then they would be used to that role and stay in position.

[sauzee-god04]

Originally Posted by Jack_hibernian

he had about 4 shots that blazed over the bar. Caldwell can just piss off now

a think you can just piss off now!
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

[HibeePaddy]

Originally Posted by Jack_hibernian

he had about 4 shots that blazed over the bar. Caldwell can just piss off now

At least he wsn't afraid to shoot and had a bit of urgency in his play. And about Caldwell - oh aye that would be a great idea with all the injuries and suspensions we already have - lets drop our only remaining experienced international - how about no mate. Whether or not we like Caldwell (I personally think he's a good player but obviously don't like him because of the whole Celtic issue) we need him from now until the end of the season and agreeeing with Sauzee_God if you don't like that then you know where to go
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

[mr hibs fan]

Thought Whittaker was brutal on Sunday. i didn't think he could be any worse than he was when he was at right back, but Sunday he was a joke. He looked absolutely petrified of Goncalves, couldn't even put a challenge in and was just generally without a clue as to where he was supposed to be playing.

Don't think he was helped by the fact that Caldwell didn't look fit, but even still we can't use that as an excuse for what was a totally inept performance.

[18grigson75]

Originally Posted by mr hibs fan

Thought Whittaker was brutal on Sunday. i didn't think he could be any worse than he was when he was at right back, but Sunday he was a joke. He looked absolutely petrified of Goncalves, couldn't even put a challenge in and was just generally without a clue as to where he was supposed to be playing.

Don't think he was helped by the fact that Caldwell didn't look fit, but even still we can't use that as an excuse for what was a totally inept performance.

totally agree with everything said there....Whittaker looked like the fcukin lost boy on sunday, although Caldwell looked a bit dodgy a right back aswell

I think Whittaker has talent but im struggling to see what his best position is...considering all of his shots came from a central position and he did feck all out wide perhaps Attacking Mid
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.









nah...i'll get my coat
To view links or images in this forum your post count must be 5 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.