Quote:
|
I don't know if this counts as cultural relativism but once on a drunken night in Bathgate, I witnessed a Rangers fan from Harthill getting pelters from some Celtic fans (mates of mine). It went onto her religion and her village and really challenged the validity of her existence (if the spellings wrong - its the wine!) anyway I had a right go at them and chatted to her afterwards and told her that whilst I found the whole hun/proddie thing offensive she should never be ashamed of her own culture and should never be made to feel that way. I suppose what i'm getting at is that we are social animals and there are no absolutes, it is never simple and that is what makes culture itself happen, its that the more we interact, the more we understand, the more we understand, the less we hate.
|
these are deep thoughts and no doubt true but the test of relativism would be say if the Pope decreed that all non-catholics could be tortured into converting or recanting or whatever (historically possible). Suppose your Harthill example took a turn for the worst (physically) and the protestant was "excommunicated" permanently - from the catholic perspective that would be their culture and justifed in those terms - but if you agree with me that that would be a morally repugnant act then we both need to explain why. Understanding other cultures is all well and good but what matters is when they cross the line.
p.s this has nothing to do with religion!!!